Very Good - 1 Series E87
Over 11 years old, apart from wear parts and a few minor issues, everything is original. Had the air flow meter in the first year, rear right and left window mechanisms, and the blue relay.
Model and generation reliability insights from verified owners. Variants are selected when adding reviews.
Owners rate reliability 3.5/5 across 303 owner reviews.
Most reported issues:
These ratings and mentions are owner evidence, not a prediction of failure probability.
Mentioned in 62 of 303 owner reviews.
Excellent road holding, no timing belt to worry about. However, there's premature tire wear and issues with the turbo.
Read the owner review
Mentioned in 42 of 303 owner reviews.
Despite good handling and design, the engine had significant issues. Timing belt, crankshaft, and balance shaft gears failed at 90,000 km. Thankfully covered by warranty, as it would have cost €6000.…
Read the owner review
Mentioned in 41 of 303 owner reviews.
The car is a good highway cruiser but suffers from excessive tire wear and a consistently high engine oil level. These issues require attention and potentially costly repairs.
Read the owner review
Mentioned in 41 of 303 owner reviews.
The starter is causing issues. There are vibrations when starting on an incline. The car is economical and handles well, but the suspension is firm and the interior space is cramped.
Read the owner review
Mentioned in 37 of 303 owner reviews.
A very pleasant car, with just the right amount of power. 143 hp is more than enough, but not too much as the vehicle is heavy. Top speed 212 km/h. The gearbox is incredibly pleasant. Not comfortable…
Read the owner review
One review can mention several issues. Categories reflect owner tagging; excerpts describe individual experiences and may not discuss the tagged issue.
Methodology: only approved, email-validated reviews available in the active language for this generation are included. These are self-selected owner experiences, not a representative survey.
303 of 303 owner reviews identify an engine. Fewer than five reviews is marked as limited data, an editorial threshold. Ratings describe these owners' experiences, not an engine ranking.
| Engine | Owner reliability rating | Reviews | Most reported issues | ||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 116i (115 Hp) (N45B16A) | 3.6/5 | 8 | No categories reported; not evidence of fault-free ownership. | ||||||||||||||||
| 116i (122 Hp) (N43B20A) | 3.4/5 | 19 | No categories reported; not evidence of fault-free ownership. | ||||||||||||||||
| 118i (129 Hp) (N46B20B) | 3.7/5 | 9 | No categories reported; not evidence of fault-free ownership. | ||||||||||||||||
| 118i (143 Hp) (N43B20A) | 3.8/5 | 17 | No categories reported; not evidence of fault-free ownership. | ||||||||||||||||
Show 4 more engines
|
|||||||||||||||||||
| Engine | Owner reliability rating | Reviews | Most reported issues | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 118d (122 Hp) (M47TU2D20) | 3.5/5 | 44 | No categories reported; not evidence of fault-free ownership. | ||||
| 118d (143 Hp) (N47D20C) | 3.1/5 | 55 | No categories reported; not evidence of fault-free ownership. | ||||
| 120d (163 Hp) (M47TU2D20) | 3.7/5 | 43 | No categories reported; not evidence of fault-free ownership. | ||||
| 120d (177 Hp) (N47D20C) | 3.6/5 | 36 | No categories reported; not evidence of fault-free ownership. | ||||
Show 1 more engine
|
|||||||
Over 11 years old, apart from wear parts and a few minor issues, everything is original. Had the air flow meter in the first year, rear right and left window mechanisms, and the blue relay.
No excursions off the road with the sports chassis, impressive. However, comfort is altered on degraded roads with 18-inch wheels. Passenger seat warning light issue, a module fixes the light for €50.
Issue: Starter motor. The car has sporty handling, a powerful engine and chassis, and electrically adjustable bucket seats. However, it hesitates a bit on startup. The damper pulley issue occurred at 180,000 km, which is its only significant problem.
Excellent road holding, no timing belt to worry about. However, there's premature tire wear and issues with the turbo.
Clutch juddering on startup. DTC hydraulic unit is broken and needs replacement for 2400 Euros.
A clutch at this mileage is not normal!
Despite a minor issue with the catalytic converter (replaced under warranty), this car has been excellent. It's a joy to drive with great handling and a solid feel. The interior is practical and the build quality is impressive for its class. Highly recommended for anyone looking for a compact premium hatchback.
This 1 Series E87 is a very good car. It's a pleasure to drive and has a lot of character.
No problems reported.
The timing belt failure is a scandalous issue. While the car is beautiful to look at, the interior is disappointing. This major mechanical problem overshadows any positive aspects.
The car has good handling and power. However, there are issues with the clutch, flywheel, and start-stop system.
The car is unreliable. The clutch judders and BMW refused to cover the full cost of the timing chain replacement, which is scandalous.
The chassis is great, but the lack of power is noticeable. The clutch kit has 200,000 km on it.
Great fuel economy, road handling, build quality, and performance. However, maintenance costs are high, and the timing chain had to be replaced at 25,000 km.
The car is a good highway cruiser but suffers from excessive tire wear and a consistently high engine oil level. These issues require attention and potentially costly repairs.
Faults: Small cabin | Problems: Timing belt/accessory belt failure
The EGR valve is malfunctioning, causing performance issues and potentially higher emissions. Requires replacement or repair.
Vehicle model too low (rubs on speed bumps). Too many warning lights for one issue. Left front parking light. Engaging reverse, clutch. Parking brake doesn't hold well on slopes.
A very pleasant car, with just the right amount of power. 143 hp is more than enough, but not too much as the vehicle is heavy. Top speed 212 km/h. The gearbox is incredibly pleasant. Not comfortable over 100 km/h, speed is not felt, so pedestrians can feel it :) When a warning light comes on, it turns into a Christmas tree, everything lights up, e.g., flat tire, red pressure warning, indicating there is an issue. Window problem where it fell into the door.
Remember the timing chain failures on N47 engines? Well, here's the bad news: ALL E9X equipped with an N47 produced between 01.03.2007 and 01.03.2011 are affected by timing chain and crankshaft failure!!! An internal BMW memo appeared in German, leaked by who knows who, and translated into English. We learn that the 16d, 18d, and 20d engines face 2 cases of problems: For the period 01.03.2007 to 05.01.2009 ==> crankshaft and timing chain failure. For the period 05.01.2009 to 01.03.2011 ==> chain failure due to faulty guides.
Despite good handling and design, the engine had significant issues. Timing belt, crankshaft, and balance shaft gears failed at 90,000 km. Thankfully covered by warranty, as it would have cost €6000. I paid €190 for fluids, antifreeze, and seals. This is a known BMW issue they don't acknowledge, disappointing for a premium brand. Also had to replace the damper pulley, idler pulley, tensioner, and accessory belt.
Quiet, comfortable, excellent suspension, pleasant to drive. However, no engine temp display on the dashboard. Basic equipment is a bit limited. EGR cooler broke at 200,000 km, requiring full EGR valve replacement as it's not sold separately. Timing chain stretched at 230,000 km, but BMW covered it despite non-BMW servicing. Water pump replaced at 155,000 km due to normal wear, costing €180 for the part alone. DPF needed cleaning at 260,000 km.
Despite good handling, power, and reliability, the insurance cost is high. There are vibrations in the cabin and noticeable wind noise on the highway. The only other issue was a sunroof malfunction, which was resolved with a simple 20-second button reset.
My car suffered a timing chain failure at 191,000 km, resulting in engine damage. The repair cost exceeded the car's value, forcing a very low resale price.
The car's clutch is experiencing issues, specifically with the rear axle clutch.
Driving, power, size. Reliability issues. Turbo problems.
The starter is causing issues. There are vibrations when starting on an incline. The car is economical and handles well, but the suspension is firm and the interior space is cramped.
Good handling and looks, but the comfort, finish, and fuel consumption are disappointing. Rear differential failed at 80,000 km. BMW considers this normal and offers no support, which is important to know.
This car has an issue with its suspension, making the ride harsh. Additionally, there are problems with the water pump, rear tie rod, and front ball joint.
Issues: 0 | Pros: Handling, Reliability | Cons: Suspension comfort, Lack of storage
The car's reliability needs review. The suspension is firm, and the after-sales service is terrible. The timing chain is also noisy.
Reliable, enjoyable to drive, good on long trips. However, cramped interior, not very comfortable, and fuel-hungry in city driving. Timing chain tensioner issues reported.
The car offers good power and handling. However, the interior plastic quality is disappointing, and the timing chain is a known issue.
Qualities: Overtakes | Defects: Squeaks | Problems: None
The 1 Series E87 is a joy to drive. Its driving dynamics are excellent, making it a pleasure on both city streets and winding roads. There are no significant drawbacks to report; it's a well-rounded and enjoyable car.
The car has a very stiff suspension. Otherwise, there have been no issues to date.
The 1 Series E87 is a very good car, especially for its class. The comfort of the adjustable leather seats (electric) is exceptional. It offers impressive power for a compact diesel. The styling is also a strong point.
This car suffers from a problem with its suspension. While it offers good torque, reasonable fuel consumption, and enjoyable driving dynamics, the sporty suspension is quite stiff, and the storage and trunk space are also lacking. Fortunately, there are no other significant issues.
The engine is extremely torquey, and the driving position is sporty. However, the suspension is firm, especially if you have a fragile back. No issues so far.
Sporty driving, a true rear-wheel drive. Expensive maintenance, prohibitive price of original parts. Intake manifold at 320,000 km cost €1200. Rear axle at 390,000 km.
The car's interior is plagued by unpleasant noises, detracting significantly from the driving experience. While the coupé's aesthetics, performance, and fuel economy are commendable, the persistent diesel engine noise is a major drawback. Unfortunately, there are no redeeming factors to offset this.
Pros: Power, comfort, fuel economy. Cons: Steering wheel insert wear, no engine temperature gauge. Problems: Small turbo, intake, EGR valve solenoid at 154,000 km.
Qualities: Monstrous torque, sporty diesel vehicle, sporty look, very comfortable gears | Defects: M steering wheel leather, sunroof noise on the highway | Problems: Timing chain noise, I'm keeping my fingers crossed to keep it..
Timeless. Great handling. Excellent. Many qualities. But. Be careful. With acceleration. In the rain. And. Don't put it. In the hands. Of a young driver. The BMW. Is a safe bet. 👍
Rear-wheel drive provides a great kick when you accelerate. The interior/exterior finish is also good. However, the timing chain and gearbox vibrate at idle. The after-sales service is terrible; I regret buying this BMW and advise others to avoid it. BMW doesn't cover anything...
Very pretty little coupe, powerful acceleration, really good. It consumes nothing considering the power. For now, no problems.
2014 timing chain replacement covered by BMW (recall). No issues until 120,000 km, then suddenly automatic gearbox problems (needs replacement for approx. €7,000) + exhaust manifold leak (diagnostic cost over €400). Very disappointing for a new car bought for €55,000, pampered in both maintenance and driving. Excessive maintenance costs.
Everything to like: very economical for the number of horses, reacts very quickly for overtaking, and comfort/silence are honored.
To get the most out of this car. You must use Total Excelium fuel. And every 5000km. Add a bottle of FAP cleaner from Total. To optimize. The best. And engine longevity. Bi-turbo.
The engine, fuel economy, and performance are superior to the competition. However, the after-sales service is arrogant, the price is high, and the interior finish is mediocre for a premium brand. Additionally, the electric window lifters fail in very cold weather, there are electronic issues with door locks, air noise in frameless doors, and the handbrake gets stuck when reversing.
The car is beautiful inside and out, rear-wheel drive. The engine is great with its twin-turbo setup.
Qualities: road holding | Defects: hesitation at 1700 rpm | Problems: battery; car radio, bumper trim detached
Good compact, very pleasant to drive and very economical: 6.1 l for 204 HP. Exudes quality but... see defects. Fragile: Timing chain, intake manifold (it's plastic...), turbos. (The chain was covered by BMW, which is something...). Braking in heavy rain is rock 'n' roll. BMW reliability is a distant memory. First and last BMW. Car is becoming too common.
I like the E82 coupe, it reminds me of the 3 Series E46. I can't speak to quality having had an engine failure. Oil leak, valve cover. Unfortunately, after 1 month of use, engine failure. I've never seen such a fragile diesel. I realized I bought the aesthetics instead of the mechanics. Very disappointed. Engine almost impossible to find and very expensive, 3k used with high mileage. Engine failure.
Engine torque, fuel economy to power ratio, great body lines. Rear passenger space is limited. DPF failure leads to intake manifold damage.
The car's electronics have been a significant issue, with problems in the window and central locking systems. This is unacceptable given the price point.
Excellent road holding/handling, power in the revs thanks to the twin-turbo, very low fuel consumption, nice look in the E82 coupé. Unpleasant sound, some vibrations (diesel). Rear LED lights defective.
While the driving pleasure and finish are commendable, the elitist price and noisy shock absorbers in winter, along with wear on the driver's seat bolster near the door, detract from the overall experience.
Excellent compromise of size, very complete equipment, and driving pleasure. So far, no issues, fingers crossed and regular maintenance done!
The car is powerful and fuel-efficient, averaging 6.4l/100km. However, the ride is firm due to 18-inch wheels (non-runflat tires) and the sport chassis. No other significant issues found.
Impressive handling, impressive torque, fun vehicle, really, gearbox very well-staged for sporty driving, rear-wheel drive. Impressive noise (tractor), wiper vibration in the pedal, yes, yes, you feel the wipers moving in the pedals. Be careful with the timing chain on all 2L diesel engines: 116d, 118d, 120d, 123d covered for me due to BMW maintenance (at 50,000km), not covered if not maintained by a garage (at least).
Qualities: Driving pleasure, design | Defects: Cost, reliability | Problems: Automatic gearbox failure.
Qualities: Nice chassis (M sport chassis) | Defects: Dreadful fuel consumption and reliability! | Problems: Timing chain (covered by BMW), High-pressure fuel pump (not covered) €2500?, Glow plug module (not covered) €180 + labor, Alarm module (not covered) €150 + labor, Rear axle replaced (not covered) €2000?, Injectors (not covered) €1000?, Turbos (both), Vacuum hoses.
Quiet, strong engine torque, lively acceleration, very classy full leather with heated memory seats. Spacious trunk (coupe version). Fragile 18" rims, slightly stiff suspension, a bit floaty at the rear at high speed. Useless and in my opinion dangerous Start&Stop for the 2 turbos (lubrication issue!). Seats don't return to position after tilting. Sometimes comfort entry malfunctions (window bugs) but rarely. It happens when I have my key in my pocket. Oil quality sensor leak (1 seal at 4?), oil vapor breather hose seepage (15?), "soft touch" steering wheel cover peeling (50?).
Good highway car, engine revs high, quiet operation. However, the ride is quite stiff on country roads, especially with 18" run-flat tires. Switching to non-run-flats didn't help. The rear suspension bounces a lot, causing the rear end to feel unsettled. Additionally, the driver's seat squeaks a bit, and the driver's side window sometimes malfunctions in 'comfort access' mode, often with issues opening. With the key fob nearby, it can be problematic.
The vehicle requires a little time to adapt to driving, especially if you come from a naturally aspirated, front-wheel-drive engine. Torquey vehicle: It's more like a small, quiet tourer, stable, yet spirited and agile, capable of eating up highway miles without tiring you. The interior is elegant but unadorned (2008), very adaptable driving position. The rear bench folds very squarely, and in two-seater mode (for the 5-seater version), it creates a large, flat cargo area.
The car has experienced numerous significant issues. These include rapid tire wear, sensor malfunctions, the need to replace the belt, and alternator problems. The only positive aspect is the comfortable ride.
This car is generally reliable and offers good highway comfort. However, the chassis is stiff, making bumps and potholes jarring. The suspension is too hard, and over time, various parasitic noises have appeared. A significant issue is an oil leak leading to power loss above 2500 RPM.
The car has had issues with its sensors. While it offers good fuel economy, appearance, comfort, power, quality, and reliability (after a timing chain replacement at 220,000 km), the maintenance costs and handling are drawbacks. Specific problems include the timing chain (at 220,000 km), particulate filter, and engine temperature sensor.
Strengths: road holding, acceleration, driving pleasure on the highway | Weaknesses: Very stiff suspension in town (I have a Sport Design version, it's a shame there's no option to soften the suspension) | Problems: Clogged particulate filter, BMW quote: 1886 euro
Very good, exceptional and very economical engine, impeccable interior finish, top sport seats. Incomparable road holding, a true sports car. However, the suspension is firm, there are parasitic noises in the dashboard, and maintenance costs are high. The only real issue is those darn dashboard noises.
Expensive to maintain, ages poorly. Had to replace 2 turbos in 50,000 km.
Excellent finish and power. The interior is a bit small for my taste, with a small trunk and a lack of storage space. No issues currently.
Safe, attractive, powerful (easily reaches advertised top speed and beyond). Top speed 228 km/h.
Driving pleasure, performance, and fuel economy are great. However, engine reliability is a major concern, particularly with the DPF, EGR valve, and turbo. The DPF had to be replaced twice within a 10,000 km interval, and the EGR valve failed.
Exceptional pickup and speed. Very low. No issues.
Its driving experience is a real pleasure. However, the soundproofing and rear-seat space (habitability) could be improved. Starting the car in cold weather (below 0 degrees) can be a struggle, with the coolant warning light coming on despite sufficient fluid. It also tends to smoke a lot in temperatures between 0 and 2 degrees. But everything is fine when it's above 5 degrees. No issues!
Driving pleasure, low fuel consumption, and good performance for safely overtaking another vehicle. Average comfort on poor roads, lack of interior storage. No problems.
Disappointing plastic quality for its price. Expensive for the material quality, run-flat tires are costly and wear out faster than those on a traction-based car like an A3. Squealing noise at startup from the damper pulley. Parking sensors are faulty. Annoying plastic creaks from the dashboard and headliner.
The car review highlights a significant issue with the timing chain. This is a critical component, and its failure can lead to severe engine damage. Owners should be aware of potential costs associated with this problem.
Excellent handling, sporty feel, and a powerful engine make this a great car. The only drawbacks are its tendency to slide on snow (I should have opted for xDrive) and a slightly small trunk.
Complaint: Small trunk, understandable as it's a compact car. Some parasitic noises in the dashboard due to a rather stiff chassis.
Magnificent design with a very aggressive front end with the M package. Driving pleasure. Interior finish incomparable to its competitors from the same year. Comfortable. Playful, but struggles to break traction when aids aren't off compared to my 330D E46 which breaks traction easily even with aids on. Good acceleration/resumption.
Engine is powerful and fuel-efficient. However, reliability is poor, with numerous parasitic noises from day one (more than a 90,000km Kangoo), suspension noise, clutch failed at 15,000km, then flywheel failed. 9 service visits in 18 months! Unacceptable for this price point. Also poor comfort and terrible after-sales service in Reunion.
Qualities: Fuel consumption/performance ratio, rear-wheel drive handling, acceleration. Flaws: Uncomfortable suspension with run-flat tires, "manly" clutch with too long a travel (a recurring BMW fault), difficult to use in the city. Problems: Rear lights changed under warranty, passenger mirror varnish blistering (repainted under warranty), hood paint fragile to stone impacts.
Powerful, comfortable, and not too expensive to maintain at the dealership. I wanted a car that wasn't too big, but was powerful and comfortable, and this car is all of that. However, the trunk is a bit small, and there's a timing chain issue with engine failure.
Pros: Propulsion generates no effort on the steering during corner exits, very good trajectory precision. Driving pleasure. Cons: Too low for my wife (but okay). Problems: Driver's side seat side airbags deflate, impossible to switch to "high beam" mode on a night drive.
The clutch had to be redone three times under warranty. It was jerky and apparently an electronic issue. It still happens occasionally when cold, and I've gotten used to it. Turbo failed at 113,000 km.
Comfort and road holding are good, but there are vibrations in the clutch pedal and an issue with the electronics, possibly part 40.
Qualities: performance/consumption, soundproofing, gearbox, linear power without brutality, sporty handling thanks to rear-wheel drive. Ideal car for a single person (or a couple without children) who drives a lot | Flaws: stiff suspension, very hard and expensive run-flat tires, snowy roads (luckily that never happens where I live). | Problems: none, impeccable so far at 162,000km. You can find maintenance equivalent to BMW for cheaper, and an oil change every 32,000km is reasonable!
Ideal for a couple, nice interior design, austere but functional, very good steering (RWD), good acceleration and responsiveness, paint holds up well over time. Downsides: harsh ride due to Run Flat tires. No storage. For city driving, I add an additive to the diesel to prevent DPF and injector clogging issues. Returned to the garage at 60,000km due to the N47 engine problem: timing chain poorly held by short guides, causing slack and chain elongation. See...
Reliability, power, decent finish. No issues reported. Clutch replaced under warranty twice.
It consumes little but is not very pleasant to drive compared to the first generation 120d 163 hp (that one had real pleasure, very good engine). Interior noise on the dashboard, the first was very unpleasant in the city. Clutch failed, stop-start battery. Anyway, there are still many problems, but I'll wait to list them. I'll try to sell it before.
Excellent car, 296,000 km on the odometer, always serviced at BMW. Luxury version from 2009, automatic transmission with some options. Problem with the PDC module for a few weeks. I disassembled it and found oxidation on the electronic board (known issue on this car). I will replace it myself with a used part given the price at BMW (almost €700) and the mileage. Turbo broke at 218,000 km for €1,900 including service and right rear ABS sensor.
It's still a BMW, solid engine, pleasant sports steering wheel, quite supple steering, good road holding (except in snow), comfortable sports seats, pretty exterior. However, the leather on the bucket seats tears easily, the audio system is mediocre, and the run-flat tires are too hard (unpleasant on damaged roads). There are also unbearable creaks and cracks from the dashboard plastics (zero plastic quality). Engine noise is amplified when the AC is turned on, and I'm probably forgetting some things. Battery replacement is around €290 (doing it yourself and buying a battery from Oscaro). The oil breather (seals melt and can go into the turbo) is also a concern.
Hello everyone, I do not recommend this model, it's my first and last BMW for sure. I bought my vehicle almost new 9 months ago and I can tell you that I'm not the type to accelerate between 2 lights 50 meters apart... The maintenance was done at BMW and yet: 93734Km Turbo replacement €1457.86 (50% goodwill on the part only) 99403Km DPF replacement (50% goodwill on the part only)
Purchased with 239,000 km. As a precaution, I had the following replaced: damper pulley, accessory belt, and water pump (approx. €1000 for good parts + labor, independent garage). Electronics... Oil leak appeared under the vehicle after a visit to Norauto.
My car's power steering has a problem. It's a shame because it's a pretty car. The leather quality is terrible, and the trip computer is too simple. No oil temperature gauge, which is bad for the turbo. The after-sales service is also poor. I've had to replace the turbo rod at 30,000 km. The steering column failed at 70,000 km, costing 1000 euros. The turbos failed at 80,000 km, costing 2500 euros.
Dynamic feel, low center of gravity, good M Sport seat support, fuel economy, comfortable driving position, nice small leather steering wheel, very low wind noise on the highway. | Downsides: Too low?, unpleasant engine noise under full load, trunk volume, rear seats too cramped for those over 1.75m, BMW pricing, automatic day/night rearview mirror and optional rear headrests are not cool for the vehicle's price.
The coupé line is beautiful, good acceleration even in 6th gear at 150km/h (350nm of torque!). I get 800km on a full tank and I don't drive slowly. The engine is quite silent, good torque at low revs. On the highway at 130km/h, I average 5l/100km at just under 2500rpm. The driving pleasure is superb: the feeling in corners (no resistance with front-wheel drive in the steering wheel) + playful side without driving aids (I mean without aids) (cobblestone roads, damaged roads, ouch:() Always starts on the first try. With snow tires, no problem in winter snow. Timing belt never changed and no issues, always serviced at the dealership. In short, this won't be my last BMW. On the other hand, the exhaust braid was no longer sealed and let gas escape before the exit at the end of the exhaust, I had to change this braid. Other than that, no issues. I could mention the rear space, but there are rarely more than 2 people in my car, and a car is for you. I also preferred the e82 line to the e87.
No real flaws, but since the customer is king and asks for the impossible: the cruise control is positioned behind the steering wheel instead of on it. It's a shame there isn't a 130d. The flexibility of the 6-cylinder is sometimes lacking, but again, it's a question of segment. A hose...
Lively, quality materials, and reliable. However, the BMW dealership experience was disappointing. I was quoted €250 to replace a rear washer nozzle, but my local mechanic fixed it for €5.70 by replacing just the nozzle. For the cabin fan, BMW quoted €500 for replacement, but my mechanic cleaned and lubricated it for an hour of labor, and it's been working fine since 120,000 km.
Good road car, no problem in snowy mountains, top-notch! However, chirping noises in the cabin and stiff suspension. Steering lock changed at 80,000 km under warranty.
Exceptional reliability. Vehicle purchased in 2014 with 240,000 km. The clutch had just been replaced. It has driven 200,000 km without a hitch.
Driving this car on the highway is an HUGE pleasure. Plenty of power, great acceleration, and overall comfort. You devour the kilometers! It's a bit heavy when starting and in city driving. The turbo broke at 150,000 km (Yes, it happened to us too...)
The car is very maneuverable and the engine is powerful enough for city driving. However, there are parasitic noises, the finish quality is poor, the turbo whistles very loudly, and fuel consumption is high.
The car suffers from significant corrosion issues, particularly in areas like the turbo and the diagnostic trouble codes indicating rust.
Constant issues: runflat tires, rear wiper motor, rain sensor malfunction, steering rack, damper pulley, power steering leak, etc. A real headache.
The car had issues with the gearbox. This is in addition to other problems like interior rattles, high fuel consumption, noisy rear door hinges, a broken turbo at 110,000 km, and a faulty front wiper relay.
The car's hydraulic power steering is a drawback, and the electronics occasionally glitch, displaying non-existent error messages. However, it offers a good fuel consumption to power ratio.
Engine is pleasant, phenomenal acceleration, terrible road holding, high resale value, excellent paint, a real small BMW. However, quality of certain plastics (not padded) is an issue, the glove box is ridiculous, the engine is a bit weak at low revs, and the lateral seat support is lacking. The hard plastic at the bottom of the dashboard is easily scratched.
Qualities: driving pleasure, chassis, engine | Defects: dashboard parasitic noises depending on temperature, fragile black paint, runflat tires | Problems: EGR valve sensor (105000km)€200? turbo hose (120000km)≈€200? driver's door + right rear door window regulator mechanism (125000km)≈€250? clutch + dual-mass flywheel (130000km)€800? all these problems outside of warranty, too bad!
The driving pleasure of a BMW, the power-to-consumption ratio, the reliability of the 2.0, the driving position, in short, almost everything. The only drawback is a slightly stiff suspension compared to a 3 Series.
Extraordinary road holding, a true BMW, top-notch reliability, youthful look for its age. However, there are parasitic noises inside and less sensation. The steering angle sensor is a problem.
Brace yourself: sluggish engine, no power, no life.... I had a 140hp Civic that pulled much harder.... Dead car, thanks BMW for its almost non-existent reliability. Absolutely avoid this car....
The car boasts excellent build quality, superb handling, and impressive fuel economy given its performance. It's sporty and reliable.
Excellent comfort (equipped with 16-inch wheels). Driving precision: precise steering, precise gearbox. Natural chassis balance, RWD pleasure. Good finish. Excellent seats. Good soundproofing. Smooth, flexible, and efficient engine. Good standard equipment on the luxury trim. Impeccable reliability. Not very spacious in the rear, trunk not huge. No issues encountered. Very reliable.
The car's electronic systems have presented issues. Specifically, the steering column and control unit have failed, which is linked to the anti-theft electronic system.
The driving pleasure, driver's position, and road holding are good. However, there is parasitic noise in the cabin, engine vibration at idle, and a notchy gearbox. The main issue is with the dual mass flywheel.
Qualities: comfort with 16-inch wheels and really powerful on country roads. The torque is really nice in the hills, it pushes all the time... extraordinary rear-wheel drive, nothing like a front-wheel drive. Sticks to the road!!! Flaws: clutch not very smooth but you feel the quality.. Problems: turbo changed at 350,000 km because I hadn't changed the turbo's oil separator filter...
The car is a good highway cruiser, but it's too fragile. BMW maintenance is too expensive. It stutters in first gear on startup. The hydraulic unit is also broken.
Engine is powerful even at low revs, exceptional handling, agile. Reasonable fuel consumption with the 6-speed gearbox, Paris to Bordeaux without needing to refuel. The vehicle is quite fun and reasonably economical. Perfect for starting to drive with a bit of power. The car's aesthetics don't age. Minimal comfort for rear passengers, boot is a bit small as it's rear-wheel drive. Suspension is a bit harsh on road imperfections. Turbo failed at 175,000 km and clutch at 195,000 km (Parisian traffic jams don't help).
Beautiful car. However, the timing chain broke, leading to engine failure. The turbo is also fragile. This is a known issue with BMW, with engine failures and no support from BMW. Avoid this brand. Their reputation is undeserved. Shameful.
The car offers an engaging driving experience with a great chassis, strong engine performance, and appealing looks. However, the engine noise can be unpleasant, the suspension firm (especially with the M package), and there are dashboard rattles. A specific electronic issue with a 'engine pressure sensor' was also noted.
Issue: Power steering box had slight play, tightened immediately at the dealership.
Exceptional, responsive, aggressive driving from low RPMs, turbo present at all RPMs, linear and aggressive, no lag. At 175,000 km, I only changed the right front shock absorber (60 euros) last week; otherwise, only wear-and-tear parts. Everything is DIY. I've had it since 2006 (54,000 km) and still love the timeless look.
Exceptional driving pleasure for a diesel of this category. Consumption 6.5l. Reliability of the mechanical assembly, bodywork, and peripherals. 293,000 km, no issues so far...apart from usual maintenance. Safe car and guaranteed driving pleasure. Torque-rich and very flexible with 163 hp, sufficient for daily use. Given the current car park configuration, I wouldn't change for anything with today's cars. | Defects: Rarity in very good condition | Problems:
The car is very solid, but unfortunately the turbo broke at 179,000 km.
The car has suffered from numerous issues, particularly with its air conditioning system. The electric rear right window regulator failed, the accessory pulley broke, and the AC compressor malfunctioned. Additionally, there were electronic problems due to water infiltration, a failure of the rear windshield washer, and the clutch release bearing broke.
Bought at 85,000 km and currently at 140,000 km. No defects encountered.
The car's reliability, performance, fuel consumption, durability, and aesthetics are excellent. However, the rear seats and trunk are too small, rearward visibility is poor, and the run-flat tires are a drawback. No other significant issues reported.
Excellent qualities, but with minor dashboard noises. No major problems.
Qualities: Handling, Highway Comfort, Driving Position Ergonomics, Rear-Wheel Drive | Flaws: Braking, Rear Seats, Trunk, Comfort on Uneven Roads | Issues: Suspension Arms. PDC Unit (Parking Sensors). Squeaking from the Cabin Fan. Wiring Eaten by Rodents. Rapid Wear of Rear Tires ;)
Driving, very agile handling, engine power, impressive torque, ages very slowly, good road holding with sport chassis. Rear space limited for legroom, no engine temperature gauge. Passenger seatbelt and airbag warning light comes on from time to time, dual-mass flywheel needs changing.
Driving pleasure, fuel efficiency, good dry road handling. However, interior plastic quality is poor around the steering wheel and above the dashboard, with the coating peeling off. Limited storage. Issues encountered: mass airflow sensor at 45k km, leaking battery at 55k km, glow plugs and control unit failure at 60k km, rear left window regulator at 65k km, and rear right at 74k km.
Excellent fuel economy. However, the finish is lacking. Several issues have arisen: the timing chain twice, at 94,000 km (noise) and 114,000 km (breakdown with crankshaft), it's starting to make that cicada noise again at 150,000 km. The differential was changed at 130,000 km due to a clunking sound. Every year for the last three years, the driver's window motor has needed replacing. All repairs were fully covered by the BMW dealership where it's serviced. The right front wheel bearing was noisy at 120,000 km.
The power window mechanism failed. It's a common issue on this model and the replacement part is relatively inexpensive.
Powerful and torquey engine even above 3000 rpm, good driving position, dry grip, maneuverable with a large turning radius, rear-wheel drive, good fuel economy, chain-driven engine. A bit noisy engine, rear seat space is limited, plastic noises but nothing major, be careful on wet surfaces. Average consumption: 8 liters/100km. Rear shock absorbers failed (original ones lasted 223,000 km, well done!), flywheel failed at 225,000 km.
Strengths: Chassis, steering precision, very reliable engine | Weaknesses: Interior rattles (with sport chassis and 17 or 18-inch wheels), clutch difficult to master (but better since CDV removal). | Problems: None specific, but as preventive measures: removal of intake flaps, engine thermostat replacement (always open, very common), power steering hose replacement, coolant temperature sensor replacement (new material), replacement of...
Enjoyable to drive, you feel safe. A bit too stiff on the suspension. Too many flaws on a vehicle of this prestigious brand and much too fragile. Problem encountered: fragile turbo or the problem is elsewhere, 1 injector €500 (including labor), steering column changed due to a failing electronic unit that was blocking the steering and making it impossible to start the car, steering angle sensor to be changed (in 1 month).
Engine responsive, economical, good handling, low tire wear (70,000 km per set). However, too many major engine issues for a car that only drives on the highway. Better to be friends with your mechanic!! Timing chain failure at 165,000 km (partially covered by BMW, ~3900€), intake manifold at 210,000 km (~850€), catalytic converter at 200,000 km (~1800€), dual-mass flywheel at 250,000 km (~2000€), and now the driveshafts, exhaust....
Road holding and acceleration are excellent. However, premature wear of Runflat tires and reliability issues are notable. My advice when buying: get a 5-year extended BMW warranty! The damper pulley and passenger compartment storage were also issues. At 57,000 km, the timing belt became noisy, and the crankshaft was affected. Repairs were completed at the end of December 2011.
The car experienced a broken timing chain, a serious issue that can lead to severe engine damage. This repair is often costly.
Major reliability issues. The timing chain failed despite low mileage, and BMW refuses to cover it, even though this design flaw is well-known. Unacceptable for a car at this price point and for a component expected to last the vehicle's lifetime. I'm surprised this isn't discussed for this model, while the same issue on PSA's THP, co-developed with BMW, is mentioned for French cars.
The car suffers from injection system failure, specifically a broken injection pump with metal filings present, requiring the injectors to be replaced.
The car, with 164,000 km, experienced a timing chain failure. After online research, this known manufacturing defect by BMW France affects BMW 118 models from 2007 to 2011. No support was provided because the oil change was done at a different garage. After using diagnostic tools (100 EUR, mandatory for further investigation...
The car has a noisy diesel engine and a gearbox that is a joy to use. The fuel consumption is like a camel's, and the sport seats offer ideal side support with their inflation. No major issues reported, however.
The car is elegant and seems robust, with easy access for replacing some parts like the air and cabin filters. I appreciate the manual oil dipstick. However, the vehicle price and parts prices are high. The start-stop system had issues at 36,000 km. The tires were worn at 39,000 km, especially on the outer edges of the front tires. The engine is noisy. The start-stop system caused a battery change at 38,800 km.
Engine + chassis + suspension: the whole is very well matched, the car is performant, quite economical, very pleasant to drive (even in the rain!) while remaining silent and comfortable. The assembly quality is good, the ergonomics flawless. The interior and exterior style is very pleasant and even racy! In short, a beautiful achievement. | Flaws: the materials used are hard. I have two small squeaks: the plastic engine cover vibrates when cold and the interior decorative strip creaks when it's cool and humid (but not when it's...).
The car has very good qualities. However, there are some parasitic noises in the dashboard. The battery was dead but was covered by the dealership.
Except for the engine, everything is fine. The problem lies with the N47 engine's timing chain.
Excellent car, top chassis but a bit firm with 17-inch rear wheels. Very lively engine with no turbo lag. Little rear space (habitability) and firm chassis (comfort) with 17-inch wheels. Clutch sometimes shudders in town and linkage noise at low revs.
Hidden defect due to poor timing chain design, failure before 100,000 km. See thousands of forum pages, QUE CHOISIR and 60 million consumers. Ongoing scandal. Average consumption: 8.2 L/100km. Timing chain broke at 95,000 km, serviced at BMW. NO support from BMW despite a hidden campaign for systematic replacement of the entire timing system.
Qualities: Rear-wheel drive, real driving pleasure. Engine generally reliable, although some have timing chain issues... Superb acceleration, significant torque up to 3000 rpm. Appreciable driving position. Reasonable maintenance, DIY possible. Xenon lights offer better visibility than halogen. | Defects: Lack of rear space (not for people over 175cm), especially for journeys over 200km... Stiff shock absorbers, thus tiring on long distances.
Reliability is excellent after 12 years on the road. Never had starting problems or breakdowns. Everything is original. Unbeatable fuel consumption at 3.7 l/100 km with very gentle driving, 4.5 l/100 km with sporty driving. Very smooth, elegant, powerful, and quiet. Excellent, precise, and pleasant handling. Bodywork and interior are still impeccable after all this time and high mileage. No light bulbs changed outside of consumables (oils, filters & liquids).
The clutch and flywheel failed at 140,000 km, and the timing chain was also damaged at 130,000 km. Reliability is a major concern, and the after-sales service is terrible when problems arise. On the plus side, the car is well-soundproofed.
German, robustness, reliability, look. Nothing to complain about. DPF/FAP problems.
Vehicle bought used with 30,000 km from Fiat in 2011. Currently at 211,000 km. Oil changes every 10,000 km done by myself. After reading negative reviews about this vehicle, I decided to give my opinion. Extremely reliable vehicle if meticulously maintained. Flywheel and clutch changed in 2013. Besides tires, front discs at 150,000 km, rear discs at 200,000 km. This vehicle is strictly original. Enormous pleasure behind the wheel. Road holding.
Pros: Present comfort, pleasant driving, responsive engine. Cons: Dashboard develops parasitic noises over time. Problems: Timing chain broke, along with crankshaft and valves at 125,000 km... Vehicle out of warranty... So engine block replacement (70% BMW France participation on parts… engine parts and 0% labor), clutch replacement, accessory belt, and tensioner pulleys for a total of €4350 instead of...
Qualities: Resale value, Fuel economy, Fun to drive, Comfort | Defects: Vibrating plastic, Small trunk opening, Tends to get dirty quickly if not regularly driven on highways or long trips | Problems: - Diesel pressure sensor
Exceptional handling, a real pleasure to drive, economical and efficient engine (performance, responsiveness, quiet on the highway), decent cabin soundproofing, decent comfort despite firmness on roads, except in the countryside. Very comfortable seats for the driver and front passenger (multiple adjustment options and spacious). In normal driving, good fuel consumption: 45 liters = 800 km. 5 liters remaining in reserve. Excellent, intuitive ergonomics. | Flaws:
Driving pleasure (comfort/handling compromise), precise and feel-good steering, good torque up to 3500 RPM (no push above), quality interior finish (feel, look), and attractive exterior (especially with M package and 17-inch wheels; classic models look less impressive). Downsides include noisy engine at idle, a sterile driving experience lacking soul, poor rear-seat space, and a costly timing chain kit replacement (€1800 at BMW due to idle noise). The parking sensors stopped working, and water infiltrated the housing, which was fixed for free during an oil change service at BMW.
Qualities: agile chassis, effective and precise braking, precise front axle, modest fuel consumption, linear engine, well-geared gearbox, well-designed driver's seat, trunk volume | Flaws: parasitic noises, purchase price, spare parts cost, unreliable timing chain, must be replaced at 150,000 km or risk of breakage, rear seat space | Problems: Major timing chain problem, prohibitive due to risk of engine failure around 150,000 km. Run-flat tires cause discomfort in suspension and transmission.
My car is equipped with the N47 engine, which is EXTREMELY fragile. The timing chain has a design defect and risks breaking at any moment, leading to engine failure. Quotes for a new engine range from €7,000 to €10,000. Replacing the chain preventatively won't solve the...
Road holding, especially with the sport chassis and suspension. Aesthetics, decent fuel consumption, reliability, equipment, online OEM catalog, and reliability of information from the onboard computer. Rear seats are small, plastic rattles develop over time, engine stumbles at low RPM, same for the exhaust during acceleration. Dealer service is too expensive for some items (map updates ~€200), average electronic reliability. Electronic problem at 110,000km, temperature sensor failure around 140,000km, rear washer hose clogged around 150,000km.
Interior finish is understated (perhaps a bit too much) but well-executed. Excellent road holding, good engine torque. The engine is quiet, unlike my old 207 HDI 90 (a real tractor at all speeds, and even worse when cold!). This is mainly why I chose this BMW. You can barely hear the wind in the cabin, even at high speeds on the highway. The seats offer good support.
This car is economical, has honest performance, is robust, has good design, and durable interior materials. However, the interior finish and body panel fitment are subpar. Additionally, I've had to replace 3 batteries in 8 years (around $380 each). The manufacturer issued a recall for premature timing chain wear, which came just in time. I hear of many engine failures happening elsewhere.
The car offers excellent comfort and quietness, but the quality of the fabric seats is poor. A major concern is the engine timing chain, which is prone to breaking, leading to catastrophic engine failure.
Interior noise issues.
Comfort (especially with sports seats), quiet ride, impressive handling (on dry roads), agility, driving pleasure, balance, good fuel economy.
The battery in this car has a maximum lifespan of 2 years, especially with the Start&Stop system, which uses the accessory belt quickly. This led to the Start&Stop system failing. Thankfully, BMW covered the cost of the timing chain replacement.
Reliability, driving pleasure, finish (phase 2), soundproofing, comfort (on 17" non run-flat tires), exceptional road holding (50/50 weight distribution), engine performance and range for a diesel (constant push from 1500 to 4500 rpm). Mandatory snow tires in winter (rear-wheel drive), limited rear visibility so parking sensors are essential, and the paint is a bit fragile (Monaco blue). Absolutely NO issues in 2 years! Not even a bulb blew!
Purchased new in 2009, it has only given me satisfaction. Not one breakdown, nothing has come loose, in short, I'm happy with it. I do maintenance at BMW when the car tells me to, and so far, everything is fine. Not an abnormal noise. Road holding: a real little kart. Nervous engine for a diesel, certainly enough for me. | Defects: Visibility, driving comfort difficult to grasp at first and rear seats more than limited. The run-flats give a certain stiffness on country roads. Behaviour on snow (even with...
Major issue with the automatic transmission. BMW dealerships are unable to fix it. Frequent and random blocking of gear changes. Gears climb to 2000 RPM before shifting up. Shifts are usually smooth, but then suddenly shift above 2000 RPM for a while before returning to normal. Engine noise changes at these moments. No BMW solution.
Nice design, compact and elegant, good on paper... but poor space, no storage, parasitic noises, limited reliability, disappointing performance. Known timing chain issue on this model not acknowledged by BMW. Very costly repairs for low mileage, especially for a part meant to last the engine's lifetime! Poor dealership relations, awful staff...
General quality is very good, chassis is brilliant, perfect and comfortable for a Motorsport finish. Brakes last at least 100,000 km, normally 130,000 km, same for wipers. Car radio with under-seat subwoofer is perfect. | Downsides: Hard to find driving position, seats a bit narrow, wood trim scratches easily, mediocre quality storage trough under armrest, seat fabric stains easily. Clutch hard on the knees. START/STOP issues due to battery, air enters cabin through interior mirror pillars, rear wiper hose disconnects in winter, clutch judders when cold.
Good finish, exceptional handling, no particular problems. Flaws: Dashboard noise, particularly hard suspension.
Performance is as expected. However, having previously owned a BMW, I am somewhat disappointed with the overall finish of the vehicle. There's an intrusive noise from the dashboard.
Overall, a quiet car with a pleasant driving experience and attractive styling. The only minor issue is a very faint noise from the ventilation system.
Great performance with an add-on chip, 122hp goes over 150hp for less than 100 EUR. | Flaws: Fussy front silentblock.
The car has excellent handling, powerful engine, and attractive aesthetics. However, there are some dashboard rattles and the AC hose broke.
Pleasant driving, comfort and many options. All with reasonable maintenance. Rear axle problem: axle failed at 180,000 km (exchange + labor: 1900 euros).
Good quality leather, but assembly and plastic quality are very disappointing given the price and reputation. Rattling plastic noises in the cabin. Lack of power compared to the VW TDI 130, acceleration too linear.
Qualities: Quiet, good handling, quality finish. Deficiencies: Consumes more than expected, excessive maintenance (800? 3 filters!). Problems: (Stop and go system = 500? for engine reprogramming).
Good road holding despite a front end that's a bit too sharp, which can be a bit annoying on the highway. Parasitic noises in the dashboard, poor central storage lining, very fragile seat wear.
Pros: Appearance, handling, M package equipment (seats, steering wheel...). Cons: Customer service, after-sales service, interior rattles, stiff M suspension for passengers. Issues: CAS unit (€400), accessory belt, DSC unit (ABS+ESP) (€2100).
The car has issues with its electronic components. The crankshaft position sensor failed at 80,000 km, the rear differential at 200,000 km, and the electronic control unit at 160,000 km. Dealing with BMW dealerships is a rip-off.
Driving dynamics and sporty appearance are great. The driving position is excellent. However, rear passenger space is cramped, there's no engine temperature gauge, insurance is expensive, and maintenance intervals are poorly spaced. The iDrive controller has failed, the airbag light is on, and the CD player is broken.
Rear axle, clutch | Problems: Rear axle changed, clutch needs changing
A real go-kart feel, I love how this car maneuvers through tight spaces. However, the interior finish is lacking, with noticeable noise and poor external sound insulation. You really feel the road. Additionally, the windshield wiper motor failed at 160,000 km, costing €1600 to replace the motor and the entire fuse/relay box.
Driving pleasure is great, but the onboard tech reliability is a major concern. A single flat tire with a nail cost €2400 due to electronic malfunctions (DTC errors). Repairs are expensive, with no guarantee the problem won't recur. Thanks for the excellent reliability!
Handling, reliability. The real strength of this car is its engine: torquey at very low revs, no flat spots... economical on the road... but consumes a lot in the city, total discomfort, shameful finish for the brand, parasitic noise in the dashboard, general stiffness: gearbox, clutch, steering, and... suspension... (run-flat tires). The parasitic noise in the dashboard is really annoying.
Problems: Turbo failure at 150,000 km (€2200?), flywheel + clutch at 152,000 km (€1800?).
The BMW 1 Series E87 is a very good car, offering a sporty driving experience and practical features for its class. It handles well and is enjoyable to drive, making it a solid choice for those seeking a premium compact.
The turbocharger in this vehicle has failed. This often results in a significant loss of power and can cause the engine to run very roughly. If the turbocharger is broken, it will need to be repaired or replaced, which can be a costly undertaking.
This car has an excessively high oil consumption for a diesel, and very little rear space. The front is comfortable and handles curves like a sports car. It's well-equipped for its age with a generally reliable engine. However, there are significant issues with premature wear on many parts, broken rear window regulators, and a catastrophic timing chain failure at 120,000 km, along with a failed exhaust mount and rear axle.
I am very disappointed with my 2008 Series 1 118d, purchased with 110,000 km. I am facing a major issue: the timing chain! Unfortunately, this is a problem I've just discovered. The repair cost at BMW is €4000! A huge flop for the brand!! This will be my second and last BMW. Ultimately, a good timing belt costs much less than these issues: the chain guides can wear out, the chain can stretch and eventually jump off.
Strengths: Reliability, power, enjoyable to drive | Weaknesses: Uncomfortable interior, abysmal handling on wet/icy roads, | Problems: Flywheel/clutch, rear axle
Timeless look, road reliability, not a drop of oil after 12 years, clean inspections. However, the run-flat tires offer poor comfort, and the dual-mass flywheel, clutch, and radio screen have been problematic.
Excellent handling and driving pleasure, though the interior is a bit cramped.
Great handling, fuel economy, and honest power. However, there are some parasitic noises, mechanical reliability issues, and the after-sales service is expensive and dishonest (specifically in Villeneuve d'Ascq). Seats wear out quickly. Also, I beat you all - the differential failed at 43,000 km! Seats age poorly.
Not excellent, but it's a 2005 version without FAP. Default airbag, noisy engine, lack of power. Oil breather needs changing before 140,000 km, risk of engine failure.
Engine power is great, and it's a beautiful car! However, there's not enough interior storage, and rear passengers with long legs will struggle. The rear shock absorbers are too stiff. Additionally, the rear axle failed at 130,000 km.
Excellent to drive, but unreliable. Repeated breakdowns: ABS DSC unit failed at 75,000 km. Timing chain needed replacement at 85,000 km, not covered by BMW. Wipers stopped working. Hesitation on acceleration. In short, a car to get rid of quickly after 60,000 km. Forum discussions suggest this timing chain issue is common and known by BMW but not addressed.
This 1 Series E87 is a great car. It's reliable, fuel-efficient, and has a nice torque curve. The rear axle needed some attention twice due to high mileage, which is understandable.
A recurring issue with the differential and driveshaft has been noted. Despite this, the vehicle offers good reliability, fuel economy, and appealing aesthetics.
Comfort, handling, and a timeless look despite its 13 years. Apart from worn parts, this car is indestructible. The seat is fragile and damages easily, and the dashboard is noisy. Flywheel and clutch at 200,000 km cost €3500 at BMW, seized driveshaft universal joint at 220,000 km cost €1500 at BMW, manual gearbox failed at 230,000 km for €450 used. Apart from these wear parts, I never had a breakdown. Road or axle noise.
Always in vogue, pleasant to drive. Some plastic noises on degraded roads. The sport chassis, which isn't the M version, remains very stiff on poor roads, hitting quite hard. Skids easily on slippery roads (especially roundabouts or tight turns). Front shock absorber, boost hose punctured (due to the vehicle's age). Alternator replaced around 250,000 KM. Currently at 270,000 KM, the dual-mass flywheel needs replacing.
This car has a responsive engine, a modern interior, and a fantastic list of options. However, rear visibility for maneuvering is poor, and the diesel engine's reliability is questionable. The interior door plastics age very poorly, the headliner is problematic, and the running gear deteriorates quickly over time. There have also been issues with the rear differential breaking, EGR water leaks, and oil breather blockage leading to oil cap expulsion and immobilization, mistakenly thought to be a severe breakdown. The rear window regulator also breaks.
Electronic issue: the DTC light and the brake warning light stay on continuously. This does not affect the car's driving but will require resolution sooner or later.
It's a BMW. Significant fuel consumption (in my opinion) between 570 and 620 km per tank for €62. The worst part for me is not seeing the engine oil temperature; you never know if the car is hot or has cooled down. Excessive fuel consumption, in my opinion, as I'm used to getting 700-750 km.
Vehicle purchased 1 year and 2 months ago at 199,800 km. Wear parts changed: at 205,000 km, manual gearbox oil change as a precaution (no issues found). At 210,000 km: 4 original glow plugs. At 213,000 km...
A real little rocket! This 1 Series E87 is an absolute blast to drive. Agile, responsive, and surprisingly potent. You won't find any issues here.
Superb, feisty, and economical naturally aspirated engine. For me, a bit of body roll, but overall no issues.
The air conditioning system has developed a fault.
Fabulous engine, very balanced and very reliable car. Average damping and lacks a limited-slip differential. Removing the CDV greatly improves gearbox handling. A different front axle setup (camber) improves its precision while significantly reducing tire wear. Passenger presence sensor for airbag. A 50 Euro bypass cable bought online. Otherwise, nothing to report at 232,000 km despite quite spirited use.
The greatest quality of this vehicle is its 6-cylinder engine, a marvel! Having driven it on the track several times (I must specify that my vehicle does not have the M chassis) and not being an experienced driver, it is very well balanced. The rear tends to slide slightly, but thanks to the DTC! The run-flat tires are too expensive! 70,000 km covered and no problems.
Versatile vehicle, a blend of sporty and compact, for daily use. Exceptional engine, strong acceleration at all revs, very smooth to drive even in the city. Great sound in the upper rev range. Comfortable vehicle, but avoid the M package for long journeys (+500 km) as it's tiring for the back. The run-flat tires were changed immediately after purchase; they made the car's handling edgy in sporty driving, with the chassis bouncing on rough roads. Problems resolved after replacing them with normal tires.
Engine, finish, handling, driver aids. Fuel consumption more than reasonable at 10.5 l/100 km for spirited driving. Sustained city consumption > 11.5. Mixed pleasure consumption 11.5-12. Highway consumption at 160 km/h 9-10. The L6 sound is simply magnificent. It doesn't look like much without the M package, but it can make a lot of wannabes in Golf GTIs or similar models cry.
Fabulous, very elastic, and powerful engine everywhere with a superb 6-cylinder sound. The gearbox is a joy to handle, locking perfectly, fast, and precise with short throws. Excellent chassis, good road holding, the front dives well into corners while the rear wants to rotate. Very comfortable on winding roads as well as on the highway. Rather comfortable on long journeys, even with sport suspension. Perfect driving position, particularly. However, there are low-end interior plastics that scratch easily. Rear passenger space is restricted. Not enough shortcut buttons on the radio. Issues with the alternator, rear wiper motor, and Bluetooth module (MULF). Bi-Xenon headlights (ALC) are standard.
This car is an ultimate Bavarian 3L naturally aspirated inline-6. The price/performance/pleasure/enjoyment/reliability ratio is unbeatable. Consumables have good longevity. The line is sober & sporty with the M package. The chassis & transmission are communicative (typically BMW). It's indestructible if maintained... However, large adults are prohibited in the rear. The finish/plastics are unappealing. The small 50L fuel tank limits range. Run-flats degrade comfort. The sport chassis is stiff for those with sensitive backs. It's impossible to check engine oil level or water temperature; you must rely on the onboard computer, which is surprising at first. Otherwise, no issues.
A reliable and enjoyable car with good handling and a quality interior, despite some minor dashboard rattles and GPS glitches.
The engine is undeniably the star, offering flexibility, performance, sound, and temperament - a marvel sadly limited by regulations. The look, while subjective, ages gracefully, and I love its 'sleeper' appeal. Its compact size still fits my garage. Overall enjoyment, likely due to rear-wheel drive, is high, with excellent steering feel and a brilliant driving position. It's a GT, not a GTI, making any journey, short or long, a pleasure.
Qualities: - Engine sound - Steering precision - Finish (Phase 2) - Automatic gearbox with paddles | Flaws: - Uncomfortable seats on long journeys - Access to rear seats
A blast despite modest 6L consumption. The 6-cylinder petrol engine is fabulous, road holding is excellent, visibility good, a secure car, a discreet sports car that leaves others far behind. Too sound-insulated inside (the engine could sing better :P). The recurring problem with the 130i seems to be the flywheel wearing out quickly. Flywheel issues.
This car offers a great engine sound and character, a dynamic and balanced chassis, excellent versatility, a sporty look with the M package, and a truly compact size. However, rear seat space is limited, the ride is firm, and there are potential issues with Vanos bolt breakage (BMW recall for 2010/2011 models) and gradual loss of electric water pump efficiency.
Bought used 1 year ago, French model with BMW service history, replacing a V8 E-Class. I'm super happy. The pleasure of hearing the inline-6 roar past 5000 rpm is truly great. It's full of power all the time (long live naturally aspirated!). Very good road holding, very well-placed driving position, excellent mirror visibility. Thanks to the xenons, decent interior space, well-equipped (mine certainly is). A car that goes everywhere and can be driven by madam too.
This car is amazing! The exhaust system needs to be upgraded to fully enjoy it, which is a shame it's not standard. Avoid it in residential areas if you're an early riser, as it's loud when cold. Aside from that, pure joy. My 330ci had amazing torque, but this 330 is on another level. I doubt my old car could compare.
The timing chain is a known issue. This vehicle experienced a failure of the timing chain, leading to significant mechanical problems and repair costs.
Very pleasant and high-performing. Comfort is affected on 17' rims. No issues.
Excellent handling, a sufficiently powerful engine, and reasonable fuel consumption. The only drawback is the rear seat access in the 2-door model. No significant issues encountered.
Driving pleasure, excellent chassis with good tires, perfect weight balance, engine is lively after 4000 rpm, steering angle, incisive steering.
Ease and precision of driving. Good road handling. All ignition coils need changing from 30,000 km. BMW recall on this point. Significant battery overheating and partial melting at 45,000 km. Recurring reliability issues at low mileage (battery melting, ignition coil changes).
Bought this convertible used 15 days ago. It's pleasant to drive with a responsive engine under the hood. However, there's a minor issue with the throttle body making a clicking noise when the engine is hot, which is a bit annoying for a car of this class. The price for the part at BMW is €462 without installation, which is outrageous, even for a BMW, especially since it only takes about an hour to change. But otherwise, everything is fine so far, fingers crossed.
Qualities: handling, engine enjoyment, safe spirited driving pleasure | Defects: Reliability not up to reputation. Coil packs, distributor, diesel etc. | Problems: Ignition coil failed.
I'm really wondering now. Common defect on all 120i: Injector then coil to change. Covered by BMW after a blockage of more than two days. Change of seal in the gearbox, parasitic noise on the dashboard since 50,000 km. Puncture-proof tires, a horror for the back.
The head gasket on this car failed. This led to expensive repairs at BMW, including replacing the NOx sensors which cost €700 at 70,000km. There was also an issue with water ingress into the cabin, requiring a €200 replacement of the rear left wheel arch grille, a known fault on the Series 1. Despite these issues, the car boasts good soundproofing, a great turning radius, excellent overall balance for handling, and a well-finished interior.
Chassis, fuel consumption, driving pleasure. No body roll in tight corners, a real treat on Corsican roads. On the highway, however, you fall asleep at 130, no 'feeling' of speed. Top audio system (Harman Kardon). In M version on very bad roads, the suspension is hard. None.
This BMW 1 Series E87 is a very good car. It offers a great driving experience and excellent build quality. Highly recommended for those seeking a premium compact.
Good car, pleasant gearbox, rear-wheel drive easily manageable. However, fuel consumption is high. There's a slight oil leak and the rear wiper motor is not functioning.
The car is good, but the auxiliary function of the car radio is lost.
The car's chassis dynamics and engine sound are excellent. However, the plastic trim quality is average, and there's an issue with the camshaft position sensor.
A beautiful, comfortable car with all options. However, reliability and fuel consumption are issues. It lacks a turbo. This N46B20 engine has a valve stem seal problem, consuming 1L of oil per 700km.
Issues: Sensor needs replacing. Strengths: Handling, comfort, engine, reliability, aesthetics, ages very well.
Issues: Sluggish engine, unreliable at all levels. Rear axle broken, driveshaft broken, 3x ignition coils + spark plugs, 4x! Parking sensor electronic control unit (waterproofing), electric window motor, 2x dashboard electronics, valvetronic sensor (engine in limp mode). (03/08/2013): I'm adding this as it just happened today. Failed flywheel to change + clutch with it -> 1600 euros....
Very good, comfortable on the road. Powerful and allows for very easy overtaking. The chassis is quite firm, giving it very good handling. Driving pleasure on winding roads, sporty driving and very good on the highway. The little extra is the exhaust sound, which is very nice and unexpected when buying the vehicle.
Driving pleasure is somewhat diminished by comfort issues, particularly a firm suspension and expensive run-flat tires. The lack of a temperature gauge and an oil level indicator, coupled with electronic glitches in the on-board computer and limited rear passenger space, are notable drawbacks. Scheduling service appointments is a nightmare. At 70,000 km, the power steering hose failed, and significant engine oil leaks (from the crankcase and cylinder head) occurred, costing €1700 to repair. A gearbox leak appeared at 90,000 km.
Reliability: Quite simply the most disappointing of all the BMWs I've owned. Problems: Frequent tire changes, electrical sensors, starter issues. Unstable windows.
The car has an excellent chassis and great handling. However, fuel consumption is a bit high, and tire prices are considerable. The main issues encountered include a faulty water radiator, damaged hoses for the alternator pulley and belt, worn rear wheel bearings, a damaged transmission bearing, a torn flex disc, high oil consumption, and engine stuttering.
Purchased for 9200 euros at 60,000 km. Comfortable, quiet, smooth, reassuring. Good braking. Nice interior with sober but effective finish. Reduced maintenance. Weight leads to high fuel consumption. Extremely linear engine. While powerful and with good sound, sensations are average. Maintenance costs are high. At 80,000 km, 500 euros at BMW for oil change, filters, spark plugs. No problems yet, except for the rear windshield washer motor.
No issues reported.
Qualities: Handling | Defects: Underpowered engine | Problems: Injection, steering, clutch.
The best car for its dynamic handling. A bit small for a family, but no other issues.
The exterior paint and leather seats are resistant. Beautiful interior and exterior finish. The automatic transmission has no reported faults.
High fuel consumption! Lambda sensors faulty, engine light often on after repairs. Spark plug coils, lambda sensors.
The car exhibits a concerning issue with its injection system. While the handling and overall quality are commendable, the engine suffers from a lack of low-end power, feeling somewhat hollow. This is compounded by a specific failure: one injector and four ignition coils need replacement.
The automatic transmission is a problem.
Very pleasant to drive, good braking, excellent road holding and good acceleration, as well as good soundproofing.
Major issues with the injection system. Injectors replaced at 49,000 km. The door bodywork is fragile and the soundproofing is poor. Additionally, the power windows don't always work.
The car offers excellent soundproofing, comfort, suspension, and handling, along with very good braking. However, it suffers from high fuel consumption and clutch or flywheel vibrations, especially when warm. Additionally, the orange check engine light illuminates, indicating an incorrect air-fuel mixture, and then disappears after a few days. This issue seems related to the lambda sensor, VANOS, or ignition coil/spark plug.
Horrible fuel consumption: I'm getting 13l/100km for a 4-cylinder engine... in the city, of course. Reliability issues with the timing chain, injectors, coil, etc. But thankfully, BMW covered most of these issues.
Good quality (beige) leather still like new, very good automatic transmission. The steering wheel is peeling... The beige tint of the plastic is getting damaged in the storage compartment next to the handbrake. But very discreet. The electrochromic interior mirror is not very reliable when someone is following me at night. Not as responsive as expected for a 143 hp engine.
Automatic gearbox, optional leather design, easy to maintain, even for parts replacement. The vehicle design is nearly perfect, everything is easily accessible and repairable. Parts are inexpensive. However, it's not at all reliable, with many issues: oil pressure sensor, oil pump, spark plugs, ignition coils. The car shakes after hard acceleration. The catalytic converter is blocked by sulfur, risking engine damage. If you want to go on vacation, forget it.
Pros: Looks, Sound when revving, Rear-wheel drive, Dynamic, Reasonable fuel consumption. Cons: Engine very weak below 2000 rpm, Engine and electronics reliability catastrophic. Problems: Misfires, vibrations, power loss. Radio and time display bug (black screen). Spark plugs, coils, thermostats, and coolant temperature sensor replaced at BMW. Bill: €1200, a pure rip-off. I was told the injectors might soon fail and they can't do anything about it. Really... I had a Peugeot 206 2.0 HDI with almost 200,000 km before. I had to do some repairs but never this...
Good car, no complaints overall! However, the reliability is questionable. The steering column had to be replaced under 20,000 km. At 68,000 km, the system controlling the injectors damaged two injectors.
Superb handling on dry, even very winding roads (Corsica), but gentle on wet roads when exiting corners... Engine noise at idle due to direct injection, mainly when cold. Stiff suspension for some, but what a chassis! I regret not being able to find a 6-cylinder. Steering column failed at 50,000 kilometers, 100% of the part covered by BMW.
Top roadholding, handles like an extension of your hand with excellent road grip. Very decent comfort, nice interior (visually, not in terms of finish) in the luxury trim. Well-equipped for its era. Driving position is the best in its class, typical of BMW (I'm 1.90m tall). Noise insulation at high speeds is better than many cars in the category above. A 2008 3-door car, it looks more modern externally than some much newer models in the same category.
This review highlights a recurring issue with the injection system. The camshaft sensors were replaced at 42,000 km, and the injectors are currently being changed at 52,000 km. While the car boasts good finishing, it suffers from poor rear-seat space.
My car's ABS sensor has been causing problems. It's a sporty car known for its reliability, but this issue is concerning. I've also noticed oil consumption and corrosion on the brake caliper.
This car suffers from excessive oil consumption, likely due to a faulty engine oil level sensor. While the ride is comfortable and the car is compact, the recurring issue with oil levels is a significant drawback.
Loss of power and compression in cylinders 3 and 4 with the presence of carbon deposits. After expert inspection, it was found that the piston rings are broken. Awaiting support from BMW.
The car's handling is excellent, offering a truly enjoyable driving experience. The design is attractive, and it comes well-equipped with a high-quality finish. However, it lacks power, and I've encountered significant issues: the starter failed at 45,000 km, there's a steering noise at 65,000 km, and the injection cuts out at idle (Valvetronic) at 60,000 km, all of which were covered under warranty.
The car aged very poorly, with a spartan level of comfort!!!! Water infiltration under the rear seat, creating a veritable swimming pool. A hole needs to be made under the chassis for drainage. The rear power window is broken, and finding the part isn't easy. I'm still looking!!!! I don't want to buy it from BM, they annoy me with their bourgeois arrogance!!!!
Very reliable, no issues in 12 years of use. Sometimes difficult in snow (rear-wheel drive, front engine). No problems.
The car is smooth and comfortable to drive. However, it feels like it's missing a bit of power to be truly excellent. The main issues are oil leaks in multiple locations, uneven wear on the front tires, distracting rattles from the dashboard, and knocking noises when the engine is cold.
Super chassis, rear-wheel drive gives the car a clear view of the road when driven hard. 129 hp is more than enough for the average person, for merging and overtaking. Plenty of fun on country roads. But not sporty. Fairly firm suspension (I find it great), even though I expected it to be worse after reading owner reviews. But not bone-jarring, of course. Very smooth and comfortable automatic transmission.
The car suffers from a problem with the timing chain being out of sync. This affects the overall driving experience.
The 1 Series E87 impresses with its robust chassis and comfortable ride. However, fuel consumption at 8L/100km is a downside. Common issues include faulty sensors and VANOS variators.
The timing chain is misaligned, causing the engine to run on 3 cylinders when cold. This is a significant issue affecting engine performance and reliability.
The car's electrical system is experiencing issues, specifically with the ignition warning light and a faulty ignition coil.
Driving comfort. Nice cabin for its year of manufacture. Engine + timing belt. Timing belt + engine failure at 120,000 km. Valve cover gasket leak.
Engine failure at 130,000 km due to low oil pressure, connecting rod damaged. Engine needs replacement. Not a great experience with BMW.
Rigid, pleasant to drive. Good driving position. A bit heavy for its engine. Degradation of plastic parts.
Engine reliability, interior durability, driving pleasure. Braking lacks bite. Approximate comfort on imperfect roads. Clutch and flywheel replaced at 215,000 km.
Chassis, steering precision, a real go-kart with decent power. Sunroof no issues. Best car for new drivers.
The car offers comfort and engaging road handling. The naturally aspirated engine provides instant power. However, fuel consumption is high, and you need to rev it up to access its full power. A major issue was the Vanos system (timing chain) failing at 100,000 km.
Despite the appealing aesthetics and comfortable ride, the runflat tires presented an issue. At 85,000 km, the spark plugs and ignition coils failed, costing €500 to repair. This resulted in a significant loss of power, with the engine running on three cylinders instead of four, leading to an unstable idle.
Qualities: Handling, good braking, willing engine | Flaws: Annoying internal noises, air gap between windshield and headliner | Problems: Unexpected orange warning light for power loss and sputtering at medium to low RPMs.
The clutch is a bit long, which is typical for BMW. The electronic oil gauge is the only downside. Otherwise, excellent engine, comfortable ride, classy interior, and ideal for a first car.
After my E39, I find similarities... Nice little sedan, not a powerhouse. Very pleasant to drive. Impeccable road holding, firm and responsive steering. Powerful braking... Very satisfied overall.
Good car, engine a bit temperamental, do not neglect maintenance on time, 98 octane. Expenses: lambda sensor, rear axle, injector over 9 years. Good car, pleasant to drive, timeless design, small trunk, comfortable, a bit firm, consumption 7.5l/100km on road, I drive calmly, 110km/h on highway. Temperamental engine, small trunk, average comfort. Injector, lambda sensor, rear axle.
Aesthetically beautiful to my taste, good driving position. However, easily tampered with mileage, which happened to me (180,000 km instead of 80,000 km). Coils/spark plugs at 180,000 km, battery at 180,000 km (unknown if changed before). Oil pan corrosion needs replacing (road salt). Premature wear of tires. Original owner unknown. My car is not an example model as it was tampered with, but I admit I am disappointed.
Comfortable and pleasant car to drive, not too powerful. As a new driver (less than a year's license 🤣), I didn't want to go for more. But in a month, the 130i is coming 👊👊. 122hp is pleasant for relaxed driving, but it lacks power at times. I don't like being overtaken by other cars 🤣🤣. Acoustically, it makes a pleasant little sound. However, there are parasitic noises in the dashboard during strong acceleration. Apart from that, no issues encountered so far, aside from regular maintenance, I haven't had any extra expenses. Lambda sensors at 148,000 km.
Reliable car, with very good handling, certainly safer than many front-wheel drives in rain and winter. Forget rear-wheel drive prejudices, quite the opposite... it's planted... it's comfortable everywhere (city, highway, mountains), well insulated, thanks to the 6-speed gearbox. Of course, it's not a 911 in acceleration, but you can overtake calmly on...
Problem: Clutch. Chassis! Chassis! Chassis! Rear-wheel drive. Weight distribution. Optional sports seats are absolutely extraordinary. Driving position for tall drivers. Sound system is quite honest… not reliable. Anemic and uninspiring engine. Braking is meh. Clutch is BMW-style, so too high. The driving aids are useless but can be deactivated. 3rd injector at 120,000 km. Coils 2 and 4 at 116,000 km and 124,000 km. Passenger seat sensor, right and left rear ABS sensors. Active grilles stuck. Right front headlight took on water. Although the chassis is great and the driving position is good, the unreliability, weak engine, and problematic clutch make this car a disappointment.
The car suffers from interior noise, particularly a weak acceleration response. This is a significant drawback that detracts from the overall driving experience. The timing chain also seems to be a point of concern.
This car suffers from excessive engine oil consumption. While its parts are reliable, the body is robust, and the interior is well-soundproofed and thermally insulated, the oil issue is significant. The GPS is outdated, and some practical options like a spare wheel are missing.
The car has a recurring issue with its electronic systems, specifically concerning oil consumption and the traction control warning light. While it offers good comfort, a pleasant driving feel, a satisfying engine sound, and a well-behaved chassis, these electronic glitches detract significantly from the overall experience. Fuel consumption and braking performance are also areas of concern, with weak acceleration from lower speeds being noticeable.
The engine revs high on the highway, but isn't excessively noisy. The gearbox only has 5 gears. Ignition coil failed. Overall rating: 14/20.
Too much is electronic (a disaster). No spare tire, no manual oil dipstick in the engine block, telephone connector, impossible to simply change the spark plugs.
Excellent handling, a car that doesn't go out of style and ages very well over time, at least concerning the bodywork and the exhaust which is still like new after 9 years! Excessive consumption and sluggish engine below 120 km/h. Once up to speed, the car quickly reaches 180 km/h, but the instant consumption displayed on the onboard computer will quickly temper your enthusiasm! Timing chain jumped a tooth at 46,000 km, repair cost at BMW = 2000 Euros. No manufacturer support, even though the problem seems recurrent on the 116i, as I...
Chassis hard to fault (which doesn't stop FWD regulars from being mostly bewildered and criticizing based on their vehicles not holding up in comparison chassis-wise...). Annoying interior noises easily fixed. Chain tensioner at 92000km caused the chain to jump 2 teeth (impossible to start). Cost at BMW: €553 incl. VAT for tensioner replacement, timing adjustment, gasket replacement...
Exterior aesthetics, pleasant driving position, overall build quality (even if the interior could have been more luxurious), decent equipment, not exceptional soundproofing but better than many vehicles in the same class. Road holding and braking. Defects: Firm comfort and suspensions (tempered however by seats softer than most German cars). Despite assistance, steering is a bit stiff, firm gear changes. Also pay attention to the common issue on this engine. (Mine will be changed soon, tired of having this white smoke cloud when restarting from lights). Some electronic issues with, for example, ABS sensors. ABS sensors with warning light on the dashboard and loss of power (electronic control unit in safe mode). I will therefore change these famous sensors. As said above, valve stem seals...
Alternative comparisons will appear here soon.
Add your email-verified report to help other BMW 1 Series E87 owners.