BMW 1 Series F40 (2019–2024)

3.5/5
Reliability score Average
Email-verified reliability report

Model and generation reliability insights from verified owners. Variants are selected when adding reviews.

Is the BMW 1 Series F40 reliable?

Owners rate reliability 3.5/5 across 19 owner reviews.

Most reported issues:

  • Gearbox
  • Clutch
  • Interior rattles / noises

These ratings and mentions are owner evidence, not a prediction of failure probability.

19 Verified owner reports

Every report is validated by email.

What are the most commonly reported BMW 1 Series F40 problems?

  1. Gearbox

    Mentioned in 9 of 19 owner reviews.

    Exterior aesthetics successful, real exhaust outlets, well-proportioned front and rear lights, present torque, well-controlled consumption. Manual gearbox in the city causes jerks and clattering…

    Read the owner review
  2. Clutch

    Mentioned in 3 of 19 owner reviews.

    Relatively well-built car, interior and bodywork fit and finish are almost what you'd expect from a premium brand. At least in the upper parts of the interior; the lower parts are more mixed. The…

    Read the owner review
  3. Interior rattles / noises

    Mentioned in 3 of 19 owner reviews.

    Electronic malfunctions: Random issues with the reversing camera video feed. The lane departure assist corrects the trajectory unexpectedly and 'violently' without reason. Warnings. The automatic…

    Read the owner review
  4. Tire wear

    Mentioned in 3 of 19 owner reviews.

    BMW Lounge finish. Complete and sufficient equipment. Perfect engine and gearbox. Moderate fuel consumption. 17-inch wheels, M version. Comfortable and quiet compared to my old Nissan Juke 110dci.

    Read the owner review
  5. Flywheel

    Mentioned in 2 of 19 owner reviews.

    Reasonable engine, aggressive and handles insertions well. Nice design. However, the steering wheel isn't very stable, the roof and doors rattle. You feel the jolts in comfort mode (17-inch wheels),…

    Read the owner review

One review can mention several issues. Categories reflect owner tagging; excerpts describe individual experiences and may not discuss the tagged issue.

Methodology: only approved, email-validated reviews available in the active language for this generation are included. These are self-selected owner experiences, not a representative survey.

How does BMW 1 Series F40 reliability compare by engine?

19 of 19 owner reviews identify an engine. Fewer than five reviews is marked as limited data, an editorial threshold. Ratings describe these owners' experiences, not an engine ranking.

Petrol

Engine Owner reliability rating Reviews Most reported issues
116i (109 Hp) (B38A15A) 2.7/5 3Limited data No categories reported; not evidence of fault-free ownership.
118i (140 Hp) (B38A15A) 3.5/5 6 No categories reported; not evidence of fault-free ownership.

Diesel

Engine Owner reliability rating Reviews Most reported issues
116d (116 Hp) (B37C15A) 4.0/5 4Limited data No categories reported; not evidence of fault-free ownership.
118d (150 Hp) (B47C20B) 3.5/5 6 No categories reported; not evidence of fault-free ownership.

Owner reviews

Verified owner Verified
BMW 1 Series F40 118d (150 Hp) Hatchback Mileage unknown

Very Good - 1 Series F40

Impeccable finish and perfect design. A bit stiff with 19-inch wheels, but not for aesthetics. AdBlue tank replaced at 2000km.

Pros: Impeccable finish and perfect design
Cons: A bit stiff with 19-inch wheels, but not for aesthetics, AdBlue tank replaced at 2000km
Verified owner Verified
BMW 1 Series F40 118d (150 Hp) Hatchback 59,000 km

Problem: Electronics

Beautiful material quality, attractive design. Apart from the M Sport package, zero options: no camera, no power-folding mirrors, miserable visibility compared to the Clio 4 GT Line I previously owned. These should be standard on this vehicle. Engine warning light appears and disappears.

Pros: Beautiful material quality, attractive design.
Cons: Apart from M Sport package, no options: no camera, no power-folding mirrors, poor visibility vs previous Clio 4 GT Line. Should be standard.
Verified owner Verified
BMW 1 Series F40 118d (150 Hp) Hatchback 27,000 km

Flywheel Problem

Exterior aesthetics successful, real exhaust outlets, well-proportioned front and rear lights, present torque, well-controlled consumption. Manual gearbox in the city causes jerks and clattering noises. Runflats extremely noisy. Minimal living space, difficult to find a comfortable driving position. Interface complicated to use. Tiny fuel tank, average plastics, too firm. For now nothing, but the roughness of the gearbox worries me a little. By the way, if someone can confirm this, it would reassure me. And when I turn left, a noise, like a 'friction' but at...

Pros: Successful exterior design, Real exhaust outlets, Well-proportioned front and rear lights, Torque is present, Consumption well controlled
Cons: Manual gearbox in city causes jerks and clattering, Extremely noisy runflat tires, Minimal interior space, Difficult to find a comfortable driving position, Complicated user interface, Tiny fuel tank, Mediocre plastics, Too firm ride
Verified owner Verified
BMW 1 Series F40 118d (150 Hp) Hatchback 14,000 km

1 Series F40: A Mixed Bag

The 1 Series F40 boasts a beautiful design and impeccable finish, with a torque-rich engine. However, numerous electronic malfunctions required a full reprogramming. The central console is poorly designed, the ride is firm, and the lighting is weak despite being full LED. Braking is insufficient, and the engine can be unpleasant in the city due to jerky and brutal acceleration. The lane departure warning system activated unexpectedly, causing a violent drift.

Pros: Beautiful styling, Impeccable finish, Torque-rich engine
Cons: Numerous electronic malfunctions, Poorly designed central console, Firm ride comfort, Weak lighting (even with full LED!), Lack of braking power, Unpleasant city engine (jerky and brutal)
Verified owner Verified
BMW 1 Series F40 118d (150 Hp) Hatchback 30,000 km

Problem: EGR Valve

Reasonable engine, aggressive and handles insertions well. Nice design. However, the steering wheel isn't very stable, the roof and doors rattle. You feel the jolts in comfort mode (17-inch wheels), it's very firm. Recurring electronic issues and bugs (EGR valve message, drivetrain randomly appearing...). Airbag control unit replaced under 28,000 km (BMW France only covered 50% of the part). I feel like the car won't last long, we'll see… The car pulls to the right (I'm not the only one, several have reported this issue on forums), alignment temporarily fixed it, but it came back after a few hundred km. Drivetrain malfunction (random but appeared 3 times), EGR valve malfunction (same), airbag malfunction (restraint system + pedestrian protection) => airbag control unit replaced after diagnosis (BMW France covered 50% of the part, which amounted to 30% of the total invoice:…)

Pros: Reasonable, aggressive engine, good for insertions, Beautiful design
Cons: Steering wheel not very stable, Roof rattles, doors too, Feel jolts in comfort mode (17" wheels), very firm, Recurring electronic issues and bugs (EGR valve message, drivetrain randomly appears), Airbag control unit replaced under 28,000 km (BMW France only covered 50% of the part), Car pulls to the right (temporary fix with alignment), Drivetrain malfunction (randomly appeared 3 times), EGR valve malfunction, Airbag malfunction (restraint system + pedestrian protection) - control unit replaced
Verified owner Verified
BMW 1 Series F40 118d (150 Hp) Hatchback Mileage unknown

Brake Caliper Problem

Electronic malfunctions: Random issues with the reversing camera video feed. The lane departure assist corrects the trajectory unexpectedly and 'violently' without reason. Warnings. The automatic transmission hunts for 3rd gear at almost 3000 rpm in comfort mode. The BVA is slow to downshift in comfort or eco mode, creating an annoying lack of engine braking which negatively impacts average fuel consumption. Stingy options (tire repair kit or fuel tank).

Pros: Comfort, handling, full LED lighting (optional Pack Advanced Full LED), Material quality, finish, Quiet operation (excluding front tire road noise)
Cons: Electronic malfunctions, Automatic transmission hunts for 3rd gear at nearly 3000 rpm in comfort mode, Sluggish automatic transmission downshifting in comfort or eco modes, causing annoying lack of engine braking affecting average consumption, Random electronic malfunctions: No reversing camera video feed, Lane departure assist corrects trajectory unexpectedly and 'violently' without reason, Warnings...
Verified owner Verified
BMW 1 Series F40 116d (116 Hp) Hatchback Mileage unknown

Problem: Gearbox

BMW Lounge finish. Complete and sufficient equipment. Perfect engine and gearbox. Moderate fuel consumption. 17-inch wheels, M version. Comfortable and quiet compared to my old Nissan Juke 110dci.

Pros: BMW Lounge finish, Complete and sufficient equipment, Perfect engine and gearbox, Moderate fuel consumption, 17-inch wheels, M version, Comfortable and quiet compared to my old Nissan Juke 110dci
Cons: None
Verified owner Verified
BMW 1 Series F40 116d (116 Hp) Hatchback 3,000 km

Problem: Gearbox

The 3-cylinder engine, front-wheel drive, and 7-speed automatic gearbox work perfectly together. Excellent road holding, great comfort, and the engine is very quiet inside. However, aerodynamic noise is noticeable at high speeds.

Pros: 3-cylinder engine, FWD, 7-speed auto gearbox, Engine and gearbox pairing is perfect, Excellent road holding, Perfect comfort, Very discreet engine and aerodynamic noise inside
Cons: None
Verified owner Verified
BMW 1 Series F40 116d (116 Hp) Hatchback 90,000 km

Brake Caliper Problem

Relatively well-built car, interior and bodywork fit and finish are almost what you'd expect from a premium brand. At least in the upper parts of the interior; the lower parts are more mixed. The 3-cylinder engine is relatively quiet, and the engine/gearbox pairing is efficient, at least for calm driving. At legal speeds (±5%), fuel consumption is low, 4.5 to 5.4 liters per 100 km.

Pros: Relatively well-built car, interior and bodywork fit and finish are almost what you'd expect from a premium brand, at least in the upper parts.
Cons: Abysmal standard equipment, even stingy (no smartphone interface), and prohibitively expensive safety options (LED headlights). Moderately dynamic roadholding, the suspension..., tinted windows don't help front passengers and dangerously reduce rear and 3/4 rear visibility, a safety absurdity. The ground clearance is ridiculous, with four adults onboard..., presence of 'chirping', those annoying little noises whose origin is impossible to determine, my model is not spared. The price of revisions, a simple oil change..., I want to add, because the service (depending on the distributors) is quite catastrophic., Door seals peeling off at the bottom, these malfunctions are due to a lack of glue in production, but after two years, it's not covered by warranty, BMW should..., like a pebble in a shoe. The silencer including this famous valve was changed under warranty. Overall, the technical service is anything but technical.
Verified owner Verified
BMW 1 Series F40 116d (116 Hp) Hatchback 24,000 km

Problem: Clutch

Excellent build quality for both body and interior. Uses good quality materials. No annoying rattles or squeaks. Great handling and cornering stability. Very well calibrated suspension (16-inch wheels). Quiet operation in the city, on country roads, and on the highway. Good night illumination (adaptive lighting option). Economical engine with an original sound. Dual-clutch automatic transmission (DKG7). The driver profile configuration (computer) was found to be unintuitive, even laborious, but otherwise, no significant drawbacks.

Pros: Assembly quality of elements (body and interior)., Use of good quality materials., Absence of parasitic noises (squeaks)., Road holding and cornering stability., Very well calibrated suspension (16-inch wheels)., Quiet operation, city, road, and highway., Night lighting (adaptive lighting option)., Economical engine and original sound., Dual-clutch automatic transmission (DKG7).
Cons: An always generous options list... (Lounge)., Apple CarPlay as an option., Driver profile configuration (computer)., Tinted windows too light (vs Audi, VW, Mercedes)., Sales advisors who don't know their products., Tires are noisy on rough surfaces (Primacy 4)., Outside of driver profile configuration (computer) which I found unintuitive, even laborious, none.
Verified owner Verified
BMW 1 Series F40 118i (140 Hp) Hatchback 50,000 km

Excellent - 1 Series F40

Very fast car, good handling, no issues.

Pros: Very fast car, Good handling, No issues
Verified owner Verified
BMW 1 Series F40 118i (140 Hp) Hatchback Mileage unknown

1 Series F40: Nice but Underwhelming

A decent car, aesthetically pleasing, but nothing exceptional. This is my fourth BMW; the 2017 X1 F48 remains the best BMW I've owned. Quality seems to be declining. Is it due to the war? I call it my 'cardboard car'; I hit a cardboard suitcase and dented the rear bumper. The suitcase was undamaged. Comfort isn't top-tier. Electronic bugs persist, even after updates, and there seem to be more now. I'm unsure how it will age. Apart from the electronic bugs, there are no other issues.

Pros: Good car, pretty, but not outstanding.
Cons: Declining quality, feels like a 'cardboard car'. Rear bumper easily dented by a suitcase., Not the best comfort., Persistent electronic bugs, even after updates.
Verified owner Verified
BMW 1 Series F40 118i (140 Hp) Hatchback Mileage unknown

Problem: Vibrations

The car offers excellent road holding and fuel efficiency, striking a good balance between comfort and sporty driving. The boot is spacious, and the three driving modes, along with a responsive engine, enhance the driving experience. However, the extensive options list can be confusing, with some manual features on higher trims. Minor vibrations occur when the stop-start system restarts, and the cruise control is not adaptive. Despite these minor drawbacks, the overall package is strong.

Pros: Road holding, Fuel consumption, Comfort/road holding compromise, Spacious boot, 3 driving modes, Responsive engine
Cons: Numerous options (manual day/night mirror on M trim), Minor vibrations on stop-start restart, Non-adaptive cruise control
Verified owner Verified
BMW 1 Series F40 118i (140 Hp) Hatchback 65,000 km

Problem: Suspension

Dynamic driving in sport mode, even with a small engine. However, the sunroof ages poorly despite my efforts to lubricate the seals. Personally, the suspension is very firm even in comfort mode; you feel every road imperfection inside the cabin. The stalk for changing dashboard information is broken. The LED module for the front lights is cracked (costing €2000 to replace the whole unit). The free software update no longer installs in the car (€200 at a dealership).

Pros: Dynamic sport mode driving, even with a small engine.
Cons: Sunroof ages poorly, even with lubrication., Very firm suspension, even in comfort mode., Road imperfections are felt in the cabin., Dashboard information stalk is broken., Cracked front LED light module (€2000 replacement)., Free software update fails to install.
Verified owner Verified
BMW 1 Series F40 118i (140 Hp) Hatchback 51,000 km

Problem: Clutch

Qualities: Interior is a significant upgrade from previous generations. Low fuel consumption. Spacious. Very quiet. | Defects: Severely lacks torque. Abominable suspension (too stiff for normal driving, too soft for sporty driving). Hazardous roadholding. Dangerous and unpredictable steering during acceleration. Stiff gearbox (clutch is also quite stiff). Invasive driving aids. Questionable look.

Pros: Interior much better than previous generations., Low fuel consumption., Spacious., Very quiet.
Cons: Crucially lacks torque., Abominable suspension (too stiff normally, too soft sportily)., Hazardous roadholding., Dangerous and hazardous steering during acceleration., Very stiff gearbox (clutch also quite stiff)., Invasive driving aids., Questionable look.
Verified owner Verified
BMW 1 Series F40 118i (140 Hp) Hatchback 43,000 km

Problem: Gearbox

The car has an exceptional steering, M Sport seats, a pleasant and economical engine, a successful gearbox, quality finishes, and good interior space in the front. The driving aids are discreet but effective. However, the trunk is too small, there's not enough headroom in the rear, and the low ride height makes it less suitable for city driving. No major issues were reported.

Pros: Exceptional steering, M Sport seats, Pleasant and economical engine, Successful gearbox, Quality of finish, Interior space (front), Discreet but effective driving aids
Cons: Trunk too small, Too little headroom in the rear, Low car, not well suited for the city
Verified owner Verified
BMW 1 Series F40 116i (109 Hp) Hatchback 100,000 km

Problem: Gearbox

Comfortable all around. However, the engine lacks torque, and the gearbox is too long for my taste, forcing me to push the gears. The timing chain jumped a tooth, necessitating an engine removal and over 10 hours of labor.

Pros: Comfortable in all aspects
Cons: Little torque, gearbox too long for my liking, forcing to push gears, Timing chain jumped a tooth, requiring engine removal and over 10 hours of labor.
Verified owner Verified
BMW 1 Series F40 116i (109 Hp) Hatchback 47,000 km

Problem: Gearbox

The car is safe, with effective road holding. Average consumption is 6.5L/100km, and 5L/100km on national roads. The 116i engine is sufficient for daily use. The manual gearbox is efficient, the finish is top-notch, and it's a pleasure to drive. Insurance is cheap. However, the comfort is firm, and fuel consumption is high in the city. Resumption is limited to 130 km/h in 6th gear, requiring downshifting.

Pros: Safe car, effective road holding, Average 6.5L/100km consumption, 5L/100km average on national roads, 116i engine sufficient for daily use, Efficient manual gearbox, Top finish quality, Driving pleasure, Inexpensive insurance
Cons: Firm comfort, High city fuel consumption, Limited acceleration at 130 km/h in 6th gear, requires downshifting.
Verified owner Verified
BMW 1 Series F40 116i (109 Hp) Hatchback Mileage unknown

Mediocre - 1 Series F40

The 1 Series F40 is a mediocre offering. The image finish is decent, but it's severely underpowered. Its mobility and handling are a stark downgrade compared to my three previous RWD 1 Series cars. Fuel consumption, space, and boot are also disappointing. No major issues, but overall unimpressive.

Pros: Image finish
Cons: Severely underpowered, Mobility and handling worse than previous RWD 1 Series, Fuel consumption, Space, Boot size

Alternatives to consider

Alternative comparisons will appear here soon.

Your experience makes a difference.

Add your email-verified report to help other BMW 1 Series F40 owners.

Create a review