Problem: Tire Wear
Excellent reliability, no expenses with this vehicle. Oil changes every 15,000 km or once a year, no oil top-ups needed between changes. Superb, punchy engine. A set of rear tires lasts about 25,000 km, but I push it...
Model and generation reliability insights from verified owners. Variants are selected when adding reviews.
Owners rate reliability 3.9/5 across 199 owner reviews.
Most reported issues:
These ratings and mentions are owner evidence, not a prediction of failure probability.
Mentioned in 27 of 199 owner reviews.
Unbeatable value for money for a used car, engine power for a 2002 diesel generation and fuel consumption. The road holding is truly excellent, the steering feel is incredible, a real sporty…
Read the owner review
Mentioned in 26 of 199 owner reviews.
Maintenance history, ideally from BMW but most importantly that it's done! Its pedigree is available from BMW or specialized sites. Very pleasant engine, managing to remain economical, with torque,…
Read the owner review
Mentioned in 26 of 199 owner reviews.
High-flying performance and a magnificent sound with an Einsemann exhaust line. Problems: Rear and front axle silent blocks, and buggy electronics.
Read the owner review
Mentioned in 23 of 199 owner reviews.
The car's comfort is compromised due to suspension issues, specifically with the control arms and camshaft sensors. Despite these problems, the exterior styling, interior finish, driving position,…
Read the owner review
Mentioned in 22 of 199 owner reviews.
The car has a very comfortable leather interior, a sober and luxurious cabin, a responsive and smooth automatic transmission, good acceleration, and a sport chassis. The only issue found was a…
Read the owner review
One review can mention several issues. Categories reflect owner tagging; excerpts describe individual experiences and may not discuss the tagged issue.
Methodology: only approved, email-validated reviews available in the active language for this generation are included. These are self-selected owner experiences, not a representative survey.
199 of 199 owner reviews identify an engine. Fewer than five reviews is marked as limited data, an editorial threshold. Ratings describe these owners' experiences, not an engine ranking.
| Engine | Owner reliability rating | Reviews | Most reported issues | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 316i (105 Hp) (M43B19) | 3.8/5 | 16 | No categories reported; not evidence of fault-free ownership. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 318Ci (118 Hp) (M43B19) | 3.8/5 | 4Limited data | No categories reported; not evidence of fault-free ownership. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 318i (118 Hp) (M43B19) | 3.5/5 | 11 | No categories reported; not evidence of fault-free ownership. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| 318i (143 Hp) (N42B20) | 3.4/5 | 5 | No categories reported; not evidence of fault-free ownership. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Show 7 more engines
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Engine | Owner reliability rating | Reviews | Most reported issues | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 318d (115 Hp) (M47D20) | 4.1/5 | 15 | No categories reported; not evidence of fault-free ownership. | ||||
| 320d (150 Hp) (M47D20) | 3.9/5 | 34 | No categories reported; not evidence of fault-free ownership. | ||||
| 330Cd (204 Hp) (M57D30TU) | 5.0/5 | 1Limited data | No categories reported; not evidence of fault-free ownership. | ||||
| 330d (184 Hp) (M57D30) | 4.0/5 | 1Limited data | No categories reported; not evidence of fault-free ownership. | ||||
Show 1 more engine
|
|||||||
Excellent reliability, no expenses with this vehicle. Oil changes every 15,000 km or once a year, no oil top-ups needed between changes. Superb, punchy engine. A set of rear tires lasts about 25,000 km, but I push it...
Unbeatable value for money for a used car, engine power for a 2002 diesel generation and fuel consumption. The road holding is truly excellent, the steering feel is incredible, a real sporty character. The style is timeless, sober yet aggressive. However, the intake clogs very quickly, with idle vibrations, premature wear of the damper pulley and dual-mass flywheel. Braking is quite weak and the handbrake is fragile. Engine mounts at 170,000 km, damper pulley at 170,000 km, dual-mass flywheel at 180,000 km, turbo nearing end of life.
The BMW 3 Series E46 is a fantastic car. It offers a great driving experience with its balanced handling and powerful engines. Reliability is generally good, though some owners report minor electrical issues over time. Overall, a highly recommended choice for driving enthusiasts.
This car is simply perfect. A true driving machine.
Very good vehicle, good stability. No major issues reported.
Qualities: captivating engine, 6-cylinder inline, brakes, handling, reliability. Flaws: fuel consumption (economical for the performance), maintenance. Problems: silent block, nothing to report.
Engine performance is exceptionally high level. The torque and engine sound are captivating. Interior finish is still top-notch to this day. However, the seat leather is fragile, and that's about it. Front silentblock and camshaft sensor issues. Very few problems in 12 years. Overall rating: 19/20
High-flying performance and a magnificent sound with an Einsemann exhaust line. Problems: Rear and front axle silent blocks, and buggy electronics.
The car has an issue with the heating seat, an airbag warning light, a deformed radiator, and a blocked cylinder with a gasket cover issue.
The car boasts excellent finishing, low fuel consumption, good low-end torque, and increased power above 4000 rpm. Road holding is very good, even in heavy rain. However, oil consumption is a significant issue (around 5L in 8 months for 10,000km). The brakes are disappointing, quickly losing their bite. The original sound is rather muffled, even after bypassing the flap. Additionally, the 5th gear is stiff to engage when cold.
Excellent tourer with decent consumption, 650 km on a full tank with some fun driving. Impeccable roadholding and a pleasure for driver and passenger comfort. For those in the back, it's very variable depending on size, age, and whether you're in the city or on a long journey. Pleasant to drive in the city and a joy in convertible mode when the sun is out. In short, acceleration isn't the sharpest, but the engine knows...
Maintenance history, ideally from BMW but most importantly that it's done! Its pedigree is available from BMW or specialized sites. Very pleasant engine, managing to remain economical, with torque, power, and extraordinary sound (valve opening). A "mini"-M3! Rear access not very practical despite the seats folding correctly. Power steering pump, 4 lambda sensors, airflow meter.
Hello, having owned a 328ci full-time, I can say this vehicle left a mark on me with its performance and reliability. When it comes to accelerating in the mountains to go to Spain, I specify that I live in northern France and those 1200 km were a delight. I never had overheating problems, even pushing the gears in the middle of the mountains, and I repeat, this engine truly has power. Equipped with an ethanol box, I didn't spend more than €35 for a full tank.
The 3 Series E46 offers great performance with its low-end torque and excellent road handling. The ride is quiet and refined, with good interior finish. The sport chassis makes it a joy to drive.
Issue with ABS sensor and camshaft sensor.
The 3 Series E46 offers a great engine, strong performance, and excellent torque. However, be aware of potential issues with the rear crossmember and axle mount.
Many good qualities, good engine and reliability. However, issues with the front triangle and its silentblock, and noisy injectors.
The car's comfort is compromised due to suspension issues, specifically with the control arms and camshaft sensors. Despite these problems, the exterior styling, interior finish, driving position, and engine are commendable.
General quality and engine reliability. Very pleasant torque. Good acceleration. Stiff steering (fitted with 225/18 front and 255/18 rear tires). Accelerator pedal also stiff. None.
This car offers great torque and acceleration. It's also a comfortable cruiser on long journeys.
A fantastic car that offers a great driving experience. The design is timeless, the engine sounds wonderful, and it's powerful. Reliability is excellent, and the interior plastics hold up well over time compared to many other brands.
The engine is very pleasant for daily use, it's very smooth and torquey, it pulls from any revs in any gear. Nice performance even on the convertible version which has a rather high weight. Great sound! The comfort is worthy of a sedan of this range, especially with the sports seats and adjustable seat base, the driving position is perfect! The look hasn't aged and the car in general remains quite modern in its design.
Qualities: Robust, reliable, low fuel consumption, sporty, impeccable road holding. | Defects: Central locking, airbag light, doesn't like SP95 E10.
Great car with an angry, smooth engine that's cheap to maintain. A bit slow to get going, with power really kicking in around 3500 RPM. Rear license plate holder can be an issue.
While the engine noise is enjoyable and the performance is adequate, the car handles corners impeccably and the plastic quality is good. However, it consumes a bit more during sporty driving. A common E46 issue is peeling door seals. Pressing the accelerator is addictive because it's so good! Apart from the door seals after 3 years, there are no other issues. The seat leather wears out quickly on the sides.
Excellent car: comfortable, good on fuel, well-finished, and a joy to drive. Maintenance costs are a bit high, but no significant problems encountered.
The car has a very comfortable leather interior, a sober and luxurious cabin, a responsive and smooth automatic transmission, good acceleration, and a sport chassis. The only issue found was a cracked expansion tank at 160,000 km.
The car has a 5-speed gearbox and lacks a turbocharger, which is a shame. Ignition coils were replaced at 120,000 kilometers.
Problem: Brake caliper. Comfort, heated seats etc. the must for comfortable driving. The price of parts, but hey, it's BMW. 170hp isn't quite there yet.... but not bad for a start. Expansion tank + cooling thermostat at 110,000km. Oil level sensor + front left and front right brake hoses + flex disc at 118,000km.
The car has a stiff suspension which is a shame. The 6-cylinder engine offers good torque, and the interior and exterior finishes are of good quality. However, the lack of a 6th gear leads to high fuel consumption. It's also noted that well-maintained vehicles are hard to find, and even minor issues can be problematic.
Robust car, efficient handling. The 170 hp 6-cylinder sound is addictive. Power is more than enough for fun driving. The 5-speed gearbox offers a nostalgic shifting pleasure that I adore! However, the car is very low, so speed bumps must be taken very slowly. Fuel consumption is high in the city, not less than 10 liters is impossible, but on the open road...
Build quality, impressive handling, performance, sound, overall reliability, design, road fuel economy. Cons: very stiff suspension, lack of torque below 3000rpm, city fuel consumption, a few design flaws (like all cars...). Missing a 6th gear for the highway (3500 rpm at 130 km/h). Fuel consumption: 14l in the city even with cool driving - 6l to 7l on the road - 8l to 9l on the highway. Problems: door seal covers peeling off (common issue on these models), a nail and it's fixed. Rear shock absorber springs breaking (also common), battery dead, accessory belt + tensioner pulley broken.
Excellent interior, leather and finishes stand the test of time. Drive cautiously in the rain. No major issues, I address any minor ones at BMW.
The car is very cool and robust, but comfort is an issue and the air conditioning is problematic.
The car's interior noise is a significant problem. While the 6-cylinder engine sound is pleasing, the road noise and vibrations are noticeable. Handling is good, and the engine is responsive, but these positives are somewhat overshadowed by the cabin acoustics.
Qualities: finish, comfort, versatility, design. Defects: rear bushings, front wishbone bushings, stiff gearbox (especially 2nd gear). Problems: rear axle bushings, front wishbone mounts.
Prestige, luxury, performance, beauty, quality, comfort, the melody of the inline-6, smoothness. Thermostat and flex disc at 150,000 km, otherwise, always change wear parts on time and it runs like the first day.
Despite its strengths like excellent finishing, beauty, performance, fuel efficiency, robustness, reliability (for gasoline engines), luxury, comfort, handling, and the smooth sound of the inline-six, this car suffers from a significant issue: interior noises. Additionally, at 150,000 km, the thermostat and flector required replacement.
Strengths: Good handling | Flaws: Striking lack of performance | Problems: Front silentblock
Pros: a lot | Cons: not much | Problems: I just blew the head gasket
Qualities: Very nice 4-cylinder gasoline engine compared to PSA/Renault 4-cylinders and others. Honest acceleration in 1st/2nd/3rd. It spins its wheels in first if you give too much gas with ESP, so for those who find the 118hp weak and underpowered... save your criticism for real flaws.... The handling is very good, as is the braking. The look, despite its 15 years, remains very sleek and doesn't go unnoticed. Nice sport rims and its rather low ride height would even make this coupe almost sporty. | Flaws:
The car has a timeless design and a great driving position. It has aged well with quality materials and reasonable on-road fuel consumption. The engine sound is a plus, and some parts are very durable. However, BMW parts are expensive, and the cooling system and front suspension (control arms, bushings) are fragile and require attention. The ride can be a bit stiff on rough roads, especially with the sport chassis. Insurance is also pricey. The fuel pump failed, and several cooling system hoses have ruptured, as has the ignition wiring harness. The coolant temperature sensor, radiator, expansion tank cap, and rear light electrical connection have also been issues. The control arm bushings wear out quickly, and the idle actuator needs attention.
The car has good engine performance, strong braking, and a beautiful finish. However, it is too heavy (verified 1600kg). Repairs included a starter change, engine mounts, turbo replacement, and an exhaust manifold leak.
Great car if you take care of it, as with any car. I honestly didn't find any real flaws, as I only performed maintenance apart from the turbo. Issue: Turbo suspension triangle.
Comfort and power are strong points, but the front suspension, GPS screen readability, retractable mirrors, and key ignition are problematic. Black smoke from injectors and turbo issues, along with front suspension and mirror problems, also arise.
Perfect. Little to complain about, apart from the aging interior plastic. Clock, electric window, normal wear. Yes, replaced the EGR valve at 345,000 km (€56) + 2 wheel triangles and ball joints.
While the car offers smooth performance and good torque, it suffers from aggressive braking and vague steering. Several issues have arisen with the intercooler, air hoses, water hose, thermostat, and injectors 2 & 3, plus a sensor.
Undeniable driving pleasure. Smoothness, power, and acceleration (with a remap to 240 HP). 2005 model, original 12,000 km. Not much to say. Exclusive BMW maintenance in Belgium (Monserez Mouscron).
The car has a problem with the flywheel. Other issues include damping, lift pumps (diesel), turbo, and wheel triangle.
The car has a problem with the ABS sensor. This is in addition to other issues like the damper pulley at 190,000 km. The car is also fragile in minor impacts and has expensive insurance and parts.
The car has excellent build quality, a fantastic engine, and is very powerful and pleasant to drive. However, there are issues with the front brakes in rain on the highway (especially with the M-Sport bumper). The xenon headlights were burnt on the inside (a known issue with ZKW brand), and the auxiliary heater had to be replaced at a cost of 1000 EUR.
Great for the engine and finishes. Disappointing for the Xenon headlights, as the plastic lenses degrade very quickly, and the chrome reflector behind the Xenon bulb is completely burned (lighting effectiveness is greatly degraded and it won't pass technical inspection). At this price, you expect much higher quality for the entire vehicle. | Problems: Headlights, vibrations on the front axle!!
Excellent vehicle, reliable, powerful, the sound of the 6-cylinder, comfort, driving quality. Lacks a bit of bite. Backup sensor failed, replaced for 40?
Comfortable, robust, and good sound insulation. However, the price of parts like the automatic gearbox (€5200) and turbo (€1900) is high, as is fuel consumption. Issues encountered include the automatic gearbox, turbo, alternator, steering knuckle, and EGR valve.
This car has excellent interior space, is very comfortable, and well-finished. The automatic gearbox is a pleasure to use, and the engine is incredibly powerful with a unique diesel sound. However, the engine broke down at 250,000 km, the suspension is very stiff, and maintenance costs are high. There were also issues with the radiator and fan system at 220,000 km, the alternator at 200,000 km, and the head gasket at 250,000 km.
A beautiful vehicle, but plagued by significant mechanical issues. Engine replacement was required due to a broken flap ingested into the engine. Now, it won't start at all.
The gearbox is a bit noisy, but otherwise there are no significant issues.
Qualities: The power and pleasure of the BMW 6-cylinder. The comfort. The pleasure on the highway, you can feel the car is made for it. Reasonable fuel consumption for the displacement and power. | Defects: Reliability... the reason I sold it (damper pulley, flywheel, turbo, intake hose, vacuum hose, EGR valve, etc... it quickly becomes very expensive. The price of parts. It's complicated to find a mechanic to repair BMWs (outside the BMW network). | Problems: Damper pulley.
Monstrous torque followed by strong power, even more so in Stage 2 (~270hp). Very convincing acceleration in 6th gear below 1500 RPM. Reasonable fuel consumption. Very convincing road holding for a rear-wheel-drive. On rainy days, it can be tricky with a heavy foot. Brakes fade quickly during sporty driving. 5 power windows replaced in 1 year. A turbo replaced mainly due to my overly sporty driving. Classic maintenance afterwards, no other issues.
Despite its robust and reliable appearance, making you want to drive it, this car suffers from various electronic and mechanical issues that are costly. The electronic injection management box and glow plugs cost €2500. The front driveshaft costs €800, along with the front bearing and turbo costing €2000. Apparently, the injection pump and intake flaps are also unreliable.
Qualities: Very torquey engine and pleasant acceleration sound for a diesel. Impossible to get stuck in the snow with 4 winter tires and all-wheel drive, a treat! | Defects: Engine a bit sluggish at low RPMs | Problems: Front axle silent blocks, damper pulley, electric window mechanism, dual-mass flywheel (causes the car to vibrate at idle sometimes and vibration in the clutch pedal when pressed). Amplifier/tuner in the trunk floor that doesn't send
Remarkable car, 75% German Autobahn (140/160km/h), 20% country roads, 5% city. Consumption ~6.8l/100. Bought in 2015 with 114,000 km (2nd owner). Remarkable engine, impressive torque, excellent reliability if well-maintained, respecting warm-up times, oil & filter changes every 25,000 km. Front wishbone replaced ~220,000km, faulty clutch release bearing at 280,000km (so replaced with clutch kit and flywheel, which was functional but 'tired'), accessory belt.
Warm interior (Alcantara), handling, torque available early, image! The Alcantara on the driver's seat gently folds. Rear left spring broke in two, fuel pump replaced along with a relay. Not really bothersome if you're in the trade. Frosting on the front lights.
Unmatched finishes and details. Pure pleasure with BMW quality!
Bought the car at 190,000 km and replaced all vital rubber parts (highly recommended), including suspension bushings, anti-roll bar bushes, alternator pulley, flex disc, mounts...
The engine is torquey, pleasant, and very fuel-efficient (averaging 6l/100km). The chassis is firm, well-balanced, and the steering is precise. Driving it every day is pure joy. However, the leather quality is poor, and wear-and-tear parts are an issue, including the dual-mass flywheel, clutch assembly, damper pulley, flexible coupling, and a cracked exhaust manifold.
The 3 Series E46 is a great car with good performance, reliability, and low fuel consumption. The only issue noted is wear on the internal leather and a minor expense for the damper pump.
Qualities: performing, low consumption, safety, | Defects: none for me | Problems: replacement of the damper pump at 170,000 km
Qualities: Road handling & fuel consumption. Reliability of the BMW 6-cylinder diesel: approved. Problems: Vehicle purchased at 225,000 km (with complete service + replacement of Flector, breather, intake manifold) over 140,000 km driven. Replacements: Accessory belt x2, glow plugs x3, rear tires x4, alternator x1, battery x2, rear shock absorbers x2, front wishbones x1, EGR valve cleaning x2, due to a fault. The common airbag light issue (solution found online with
Engine is very pleasant, very quiet at steady speed. Engine a bit noisy at idle when cold. I do not recommend buying this car to anyone who knows nothing about mechanics. To avoid potential issues, blank off the flap valves that break (causes engine failure). At 120,000 km, the airflow meter; at 110,000 km, thermostat/EGR to be changed (doesn't heat enough); glow plug module at 146,000 km (2 spark plugs not working and engine vibrates when cold for max 12 hours preventively). Depending on use, flywheel and clutch.
A fantastic car with a great 6-cylinder engine, excellent chassis, and timeless beauty. However, dealing with BMW dealerships for after-sales service can be a drawback. Some front-end issues may arise, but they are typically normal wear and tear.
The engine's responsiveness, comfort, and reasonable fuel consumption for a 3-liter 6-cylinder make it a pleasure to drive. It ages well and offers an enjoyable driving experience.
Average consumption: 6.3 liters/100km. Starter at 200,000 km, transmission flector at 280,000 km, damper pulley at 340,000 km, internal wear on front tires despite replacement of front silent blocks.
Interior finish is beautiful and holds up well with age... Steering is a bit heavy, tends to follow road imperfections. If there's a camber to the right, it pulls right. But given the tire size, some might say it's normal. I just find it annoying. The turbo failed, as did the flex disc.
The car has an issue with the electronics, specifically the airbag warning light is on.
Driving is very pleasant, engine noise too, good road holding, good fuel consumption for a 204hp engine. Leather ages poorly (driver's seat worn), not much storage space, no tailgate opening which reduces trunk size. Steering tends to get jerky right/left on rough roads (17" tires), which is a bit annoying. Engine repair at 120,000 km to remove flaps as the engine had ingested them, EGR valve + air flow meter at 180,000 km.
Engine is smooth, nice lines. But front suspension is fragile, tires wear unevenly. Between 80,000 and 90,000 km: suspension arms failed, airflow meter failed, starter motor failed twice, automatic gearbox issues with dashboard warning lights. Several diagnostics at B 57 Terville (€480) revealed no serious anomalies! At 130,000 km: gearbox failed (€4960) at B 57 Metz.
Economy, relatively comfortable, reliable once a few known issues are corrected. Very good road holding. Precise steering. Low fuel consumption for a 200 horsepower engine. Engine enjoyment, presence of the 6th gear which allows cruising at a good speed without hearing the engine too much.
Overall, the 3 Series E46 offers a great driving experience and its interior finishes age well. Minor issues include a faulty ground on the taillights and a glitch on the speedometer.
The car has excellent build quality, good fuel economy, and is enjoyable to drive. Maintenance is also reasonable. However, the trunk space is limited and the braking performance could be better. A significant issue arose with the injectors at 88,000 km.
Firm and robust, it's German!! The front axle is fragile, requiring replacement of the control arms at every technical inspection!! Control arms (twice), rotten rear brake hoses, parking brake failed at 245,000 km.
Low fuel consumption, relatively satisfying power, very reliable car when cared for, pleasant to drive, it made me completely fall in love with the brand!!!
Driving and handling are pleasant, with a sufficiently powerful and torquey engine. However, the automatic gearbox is sluggish. Recurring issues include irregular tire wear, weak power windows, and easy scraping on the ground. The turbo, transmission flex disc, and excessive oil consumption are also concerns, with the oil cooler being too exposed to impacts and cold.
Engine power, acceleration, agility, pleasant handling. The paint is a bit fragile. Nothing else. Intake flaps removed to prevent engine damage.
Qualities: finish, build quality, power/torque, low fuel consumption, impeccable handling with Bridgestone all-season tires. | Defects: excessively expensive maintenance, price of parts. | Problems: passenger side window regulator, burnt rear lights, clutch, cracked water pipe, damper pulley. Maintenance: expect around €200/year changing all filters and using Castrol oil (doing it yourself). Rating: 18/20
Very good BMW 320d E46 150hp version, 385,000 km, 6-speed gearbox. Engine oil change due at 10,000 km with all filters, considering the high mileage and frequent use. Fuel consumption: 5.6 L/100km. Gearbox oil for smoother gear changes. Black leather interior, metallic grey.
Qualities: Fuel consumption, comfort, maintenance. | Defects: Control arm bushings, power window. | Problems: Glow plugs, lift pump, control arm bushing.
Qualities: comfort, dry grip, performance, very pleasant to drive in the countryside and on the highway, well-placed controls. | Flaws: wet grip, very tight for 5 (roominess), missing front storage. | Problems: some lights often come on for no reason (rear light indicator), oil sensor failed, right rear shock spring cracked, front lights quickly becoming opaque, high oil consumption.
Very good on the road, 5.6 L on national roads. Check maintenance carefully: oil change and filters every 10,000 km. Given the mileage, I recommend it with the 6-speed gearbox, very advantageous for consumption and very reliable mechanically. 5.5 liters of Castrol Magnatec 5W40 C4 oil. Also check gearbox and differential oil. Well check tire wear, wheel alignment needs to be done, and handbrake needs inspection (cable and rear shoes). Drive gently to preserve it.
The car handles well, with typical German quality. However, novices with rear-wheel drive should be cautious in certain weather conditions. There was an issue with the breather system, leading to a loss of power and the car radio audio.
The BMW 3 Series E46 is an outstanding car. Its chassis, road holding, and cornering ability are exceptional. The aesthetics, particularly its low height of 1.37m, and the driver's cockpit are also highly commendable. There are no defects or issues to report.
This car suffers from a fragile paint job. Additionally, the power windows do not auto-reverse, and tire wear occurs around every 35,000 km. The paint is particularly susceptible to stains from gravel and dirt that are difficult to remove.
Qualities: finish, quality, reliability, fuel consumption | Flaws: weight, noisy diesel when cold, trunk volume | Problems: cracked catalytic converter at 110,000 km. no other issues.
Car is pleasant to drive on long trips, comfortable and reasonably fuel-efficient. Vehicle has a very good balance, handles well and is easily steered and recovered in bad weather (DSC always disconnected for me). Engine has torque and responds when needed. However, parts are expensive, headlight lenses are poor quality, brakes are fragile, and the engine doesn't live up to its reliability reputation. Engine seized at 200,000 km with no prior warning (oil level okay, very recent oil change, no oil pump defects)... Absolutely disgusted as I've never seen anything like it.
Fuel consumption on the highway is 5.4l, in the city 6.1l, on the road 5.7l. The 6-speed gearbox is comfortable, with black leather seats. A 4-cylinder engine, it's a real pleasure to drive this BMW 320d 150hp. I recommend it, a very good model. Sedan trunk is quite small for luggage. It's not made for city driving due to the clutch and excessive consumption. With 355,000 km, pay attention to the driveshaft and clutch. Don't force gear changes and drive calmly on good roads with cruise control.
Excellent long-distance cruiser if well-maintained. Address any anomalies promptly by consulting an expert. For BMWs, spark plugs can require replacement, the EGR valve needs cleaning with petrol, and oil changes are frequent. Often reaches 500,000 km. Shocks and handbrake are very soft on descents. Be aware of fuel overconsumption. Check rail pressure sensors, which can show up to 20l/100km consumption at 380,000 km. This is not a rodeo car; harsh handbrake use and first-gear starts can break the driveshaft and exhaust. Be cautious when buying used and inspect thoroughly.
The car has been reliable overall, but experienced an alternator failure at 230,000 km, along with a camshaft sensor issue that prevented restarting. At 237,000 km, the clutch release bearing needed replacement. Be cautious of the melting intake flaps that can cause significant damage.
Current design, low fuel consumption (5-7 L/100km), precise steering, comfortable for long trips, quality interior finish, smooth and torque-rich engine. However, front suspension bushings are fragile on rough roads, handling is iffy on slippery surfaces, and loading large items is difficult due to the low trunk opening. Turbo, 2 injectors, and catalytic converter replaced at 140,000km (costly €5000?), and window regulator mechanism replaced at 200,000km.
Engine, performance, road holding, finish quality, smooth driving (6th gear acceleration from 60 km/h without lugging!) original clutch and battery. Engine reliability (turbo failed at 140,000 km) and front axle (4 sets of ball joints in 340,000 km), a drain on driving license points and tires if not careful, unsatisfactory after-sales service. Problems: turbo, steering ball joint, alternator belt, water pump, power steering (funny at 120 km/h), clouded front optics, rear wiper stuck, broken tailgate hinge.
Built for the Autobahn, good fuel economy, excellent finish and equipment. However, the steering is heavy (though precise), rear access is limited, and the trunk opening is awkward. Original oil breather failed at 250,000 km (which eventually blew both intercooler hoses!), causing EGR and intake manifold clogging, plus the driver's window mechanism failed.
Excellent fuel economy, quiet ride, and high-quality materials. The only notable issue is the intake manifold flaps.
Qualities: Very comfortable to drive in all circumstances and weather. Exemplary road holding, really good chassis. Car that doesn't age inside or out. Engine with enough responsiveness for its size while consuming little, ideal at 2000 rpm at a steady speed because it's quiet for a diesel. | Defects: Some parts are really expensive for what they are... Many "ailments" and reliability defects. BMW is useless when you have problems and service costs are exorbitant for...
Clutch hard, reduced storage, expensive parts. Front wishbone bushings, front stabilizer links, tarnished headlights, electric boot release, lift pump, split intercooler/intake manifold connection, 2 intake flaps. One went into the engine = engine failure!!
The car offers good road performance. On dry roads, it has excellent handling, making it very pleasant to drive. The engine is up to par, flexible and efficient. The 5-speed gearbox is well-geared. The interior finish is of very good quality and durable (Luxury Pack). Equipment is more than sufficient for this model. The classic, well-designed bodywork ages well. Soundproofing is decent. However, on wet surfaces, be cautious with the rear-wheel drive: braking while cornering at the entry requires a light foot and delicate steering. The same applies when accelerating out of a corner; otherwise, a slide is possible. Turbo failure at 162,500 km on the highway, with no prior warning and despite regular maintenance. BMW dealer okay, but the bill was steep: 2500 euros.
Engine robustness, chassis, interior quality. Defects: Turbo, pulley crankshaft, catalyst, tailgate, little storage. Problems: Turbo, catalyst, faulty gasket/cover around injectors (leak) / crankshaft pulley damper / window regulator mechanism (not the motor).
Pros: Beautiful (even today), dashboard like I like it with the center console directed towards the driver, ease of using the buttons because they are very well made, consumption and performance. | Cons: Reliability, and lack of design in the speedometer and it slips when it snows or the ground is wet. Lack of storage. Maintenance costs are more expensive than at Mercedes, which is not normal. | Problems: Turbo, fragile intake flaps, wishbones.
Qualities: good finish, materials age well (except driver's seat leather - lumbar area needs maintenance to avoid premature aging). Aesthetics, design ages very well. Driving position. Pleasant gearbox, precise steering, rear-wheel drive. Low fuel consumption, 5.5-6l/100km on highway without economical driving. Good soundproofing. Equipment. Although it's only the 150hp version, acceleration is respectable given the engine. A truly very pleasant vehicle.
Pros: Comfort, beauty of the beast, pickup, performance, braking, class, finish, consumption, all the car's details, the dashboard and very high-level reliability. Feeling of safety, great original sound system, breathtaking lines! | Cons: None or almost none, known issues with turbo, window regulators, and intake flaps. | Problems: Turbo (changed at 160,000km on mine, not due to breakage but power loss, TERRIBLE TERRIBLE TERRIBLE the Garett brand for that!), intake flaps (I removed them). Problems with the...
Long-distance comfort, handling, quality, and reliability. Maintenance isn't too expensive (unless you go to BMW). Be careful in the rain, it's rear-wheel drive. The BM54 audio amplifier is a known issue (loss of sound on one or both sides, TEST THE SOUND when buying). Crankcase breather filter completely failed, replaced with a vortex system. Watch out for the intake flaps on phase 2 models, they can break and fall into the engine, requiring mandatory removal. Catalytic converter tends to fail. Rear shock absorbers failed at 120k km, which seems low.
Good on the road, pleasant. Sufficient power (150hp). Fairly large trunk with folding rear seats. Bought at 260,000 km, now at 340,000 km, doesn't consume oil between changes and still reaches 215 km/h. Especially be meticulous with maintenance, and it will reward you! Full service at purchase, replacement of ALL fluids and ALL filters + oil separator. Oil change + filters every 10,000 km, use quality oil (Motul 5w40). Oil separator every 40/60.
Comfortable and easy to drive, ideal for long journeys. Reasonable fuel consumption if not pushed. Sound system and soundproofing are decent but the turbo is clearly audible. Very pleasant engine torque and good performance. Handling is quite good on dry roads (original suspension). Pleasant smell of leather typical of BMWs from those years. Incredible reliability of the M47 engine, covers miles with disconcerting ease. Well-maintained, it's almost indestructible, not ridiculous compared to the M57 in the 330d. Beautiful car lines and design, especially on larger models.
I have a 320 CD (coupe) which I bought at 230,000 km. Long-distance comfort (you can swallow the miles and don't want to stop), the driving is pleasant. The road holding is superb. It doesn't lose grip (cornering at 70 km/h taken at 100 km/h). When you're at 150/160 km/h on the highway, it feels like you're doing 120. Cabin comfort 8/10, this is a proper car! Rear seats: honestly, the middle person is not comfortable at all. However, two people in the back will be comfortably seated. Driving caution in corners under...
Good car overall. The injection pump cost €2000 to fix.
Qualities: comfort, fuel economy, design | Flaws: minor issue left and right | Problems: dual-mass flywheel, AC,
Engine is robust, handling on 18-inch rims is excellent. EGR deleted for optimal performance.
Issues with moldy smell from the AC, seemingly incurable. Tried all types of AC cleaners. Condensate drain not blocked.
Qualities: handling, performance/economy, equipment quality. Flaws: trunk, poor leather aging, tarnished optics. Problems: pre-catalyst, clutch slipping in 1st gear, unresolved issue.
The interior upholstery is like new! No parasitic noise, low consumption (6 liters real), everything is original, except for the shock absorbers and glow plugs. However, it's starting to develop play in the steering.
Seats are comfortable, and the air conditioning works very well on this model. However, the shock absorbers are a bit stiff. Issues encountered include the two rear shock absorber springs, a seized brake caliper piston, a seized rear windshield wiper, and a breather hose change.
Driving pleasure, comfort, road holding, equipment, design, quality of materials. Issues: pre-catalytic converter failed at 100,000 km / tremors in the chassis when releasing the clutch in humid weather (origin still unknown).
Pros: road holding and comfort, sound system, reliability. | Cons: limited rear space. Impossible to install 3 real child car seats. | Issues: gearshift leather gaiter and steering wheel leather are not durable. Plastic varnish crumbles.
I've owned this car for 3 years with no major issues. The interior, exterior, and mechanics are excellent. Its handling is superb, making it a pleasure to drive.
The BMW 3 Series E46 is a fantastic car, offering a great balance of performance, comfort, and handling. It's a joy to drive, whether on winding roads or for daily commutes. The build quality is excellent, and it has proven to be a reliable car with no major issues reported.
Issues: EGR valve, Oil Separator, and especially the ignition switch (capricious, causing occasional starting problems, impossible starts, or sudden engine cut-off while driving). Diagnosis for this type of fault varies from garage to garage, even at BMW: fuel pump?, its electrical supply circuit? ECU not sending information? When in the end, no one thought of the ignition switch and its associated contact as the source of the problem! Nevertheless, it's a good...
The car is pleasant to drive, even in winter. My wife drives it 90% of the time, fitted with Michelin Alpin winter tires. However, there are issues with the pre-catalyst, front window regulator mechanism, airbag warning light, and the yellow oil warning light which illuminates briefly at startup. Also, wires in the black sheath on the right side of the trunk were cut. Replace the sensor at the bottom of the engine block!
Good road holding on dry surfaces thanks to the dry suspension, driving pleasure thanks to rear-wheel drive and good acceleration when ASC (traction control) is deactivated in a straight line, good soundproofing when the engine is warm. Max Speed: 210 Km/h. (NO MAJOR ISSUES SO FAR, AND I'VE HAD IT FOR 4 YEARS) | Downsides: It's a shame ESP was optional before 2003, a floating sensation on the highway from 120 Km/h, the car sometimes shakes from 180 Km/h when it's windy. A bit heavy for its...
Quiet, comfortable for long trips (electric sport leather seats and cruise control), good finish, 1 year no expenses on the car and 25,000 km covered, formidable DSC. Around 1100 km range on a full tank for 85 euros (7 cents per km). Some parasitic noises on degraded roads, could have used better acceleration. Rear wiper not working but not essential due to rear window angle (230 euros at BMW).
The 3 Series E46 is an excellent car, offering a great balance of performance, comfort, and reliability. It handles beautifully and is a joy to drive on winding roads. Even after many years, it remains a solid and enjoyable vehicle.
Excellent reliability, good fuel consumption, great engine sound, and a pleasure to drive.
Despite the occasional ABS, handbrake, and traction control warning light, this car has proven to be very reliable with 294,000 km. The alternator was replaced just 1000 km ago.
My 1998 BMW E46 had the rear chassis un-welded, a known issue for BMW from 1998 to 2000 on Phase 1 models. Risk of losing the rear axle. For BMW, it depends on us. I find this totally lame. A cost of 3000 euros, and by sorting it ourselves, 1000.
A powerful and surprisingly fuel-efficient car, offering a comfortable ride, especially when compared to the E46 coupe.
Remarkable reliability, parts are relatively inexpensive. After 27 years of service, I don't think I'll find a car as dependable again.
Assembly quality, very good road holding, 6-cylinder sound, torquey and sufficient engine without being a fighter jet, but allows for enjoyment. This vehicle is 19 years old but is in better health than some that are 10 years old!
Comfort, smoothness, power, driving position, turning radius, looks, solidity, quite measured consumption for a 2.5L 6-cylinder. Specific maintenance. Leaky radiator hose poorly repaired, leading to engine destruction at only 185,000 km and 23 years.
Nothing to say other than the brake warning light is always on, even though all brakes have been changed. It still has plenty of power, reached 240 km last year, no police around. It passed the last technical inspection for 2019, I'm doing everything to ensure it passes again; no rust, impeccable 1995 vehicle. I'm looking for flaws but can't find any. The handbrake light is always on, I'll have to go to BMW, hello to the bill.
Weight, interior creaks and rattles over time... the braking lacks bite. Handbrake, rear caliper seized (high-pressure washing to be avoided).
Reliability, robustness, power, engine access for easy maintenance, engine sound... Fragile axle mounting, a recurring problem... Defective front passenger occupancy sensor, which causes the airbag warning light to illuminate on the dashboard. Defective oil sensor (orange oil light on startup for 20 seconds). Axle mounting, cooling fan failure, warning lights (see above).
The inline 6-cylinder engine is exceptional, very pleasant to drive, and not too thirsty. Normal driving on the highway at 130 km/h yields about 750 km on a full tank. In the city, consumption can reach a maximum of 12 liters per 100 km. With sporty driving, it can get up to 12 liters. If driven very gently, you can get down to 9 liters. Good performance, especially on the highway where it's formidable. Less comfortable in the city due to its weight. It gives an impression of quality and safety. The interior is very well equipped for its era, and it's very reliable. A vehicle to buy.
Good braking on 17'' 225/55 wheels, stable in roundabouts even at high speed, no body roll. Torque-rich engine with good sound. The gearbox provides good acceleration, coupled with the engine's VANOS, its 170hp gives you the necessary power for short overtakes, very quick entry onto slip roads, toll booth departures... The steering is a bit stiff but very precise. The trunk is large enough for several suitcases. The sound quality is good. Defects: Particular attention is required for the cooling system and the front and rear suspension. Might be too aggressive for passengers, very very firm suspension. Engine fan replaced by a viscous coupling. Airbag coupler and mat bypassed with a diode and fault erased. Oil sensor lights up on startup, but nothing to worry about for a 19-year-old vehicle.
Excellent qualities: The 323 Ci's engine is sublime for those who appreciate fine mechanics. Despite its age (17 years) and mileage (118,000 km), it still shows no significant issues. The finish is precise, though perhaps a bit light.
Enchanting inline-6 sound and top-notch reliability! Fuel consumption 8.7l/100km... reasonable. Successful finish and design. I can't find any deal-breakers! The left front stabilizer bar was changed at 98,000 km (60 euros). I've had it since it had 85,000 km.
A very good finish and dynamic driving experience. The braking is average, it lacks torque at low revs, and it consumes a little oil (1L/10,000kms), but overall it's an excellent car with no major problems.
Overall very reliable, with an excellent, smooth, and powerful engine. However, fuel consumption in the city is high (12-13 liters per 100 km!). Also had issues with the electric window motors (front and rear).
Very reliable car, 17 years without any problems!! Vehicle that doesn't age internally (no squeaks or rattles). Rear light circuit board is fragile (connector). Rear lights.
The V6 engine is smooth, sounds great, and is quite powerful despite lacking low-end torque. Fuel consumption is reasonable, the design is timeless, and it's very comfortable. However, the steering is a bit stiff, and the control arm bushings are fragile.
This BMW 3 Series E46 is an excellent car. It boasts impressive build quality, a well-equipped interior, and remarkable reliability. The fuel consumption is a bit high for its performance, and the front wishbones needed replacement around 130,000 km.
The power steering pump is faulty.
Issue: Power steering. Strengths: The inline 6-cylinder engine performs well, the engine sound is great, perfect handling with precise steering. Weaknesses: Fragile front axle. Problems: Replacement of control arm bushings, stabilizer bar links due to suspicious noises on degraded roads.
Qualities: nice finish, comfortable, 6-cylinder noise, handling. Flaws: some electronic weaknesses, fragile front axle, consumes a lot of oil. Clutch with a very long, unpleasant travel. Problems: rear shock absorbers snapped, significant oil consumption, GPS failure, car radio screen failure, unstable idle, ABS sensor failure, battery failure.
Exceptional road holding, divine 6-cylinder sound, very well insulated. Above 3500 rpm, it becomes aggressive. The luxury package makes the interior splendid, and the exterior is always up-to-date. Lacks torque below 2500 rpm. Issues include the expansion tank, A/C problems to investigate, and a recall for the passenger airbag!
Pros: - Comfort - Engine power/sound - Reliability (indestructible! 313,000km runs like clockwork, not a sound!) - Chassis - Aesthetics - Equipment (phone, cruise control, sunroof, automatic climate control, electric seats and...) - Finish - Robustness not just mechanical, but also of materials used (paint, metal, and interior materials don't age). - Used price (don't be afraid of mileage if the car is properly maintained). | Cons: ??? No real "flaw". The car does require good, regular maintenance and not cut-price. This means a higher maintenance budget than a Twingo, but we're not talking about the same kind of car… It seems the Achilles' heel is the front suspension; personally, I go over speed bumps almost at a standstill, I don't drive through potholes, and I don't climb curbs... So, no issues.
Issues encountered: ABS, sagging headliner, easily scratched hard interior plastics, rapidly deteriorating rear window seals.
The engine is very pleasant, quiet at low RPM, and produces a nice sound when revved. The power is more than sufficient for merging and overtaking. It just lacks a bit of torque below 3000 rpm. Very reliable, with excellent road holding and firm suspension. Superb lines and good habitability in the wagon. Used price is higher than average, but justified. Exceptional aging of interior plastics and bodywork. However, the front axle is fragile, becoming sensitive to road deformations with age, requiring several part replacements. Fuel consumption is quite high, especially in the city. Jerky gear changes at low speeds, prone to oversteer. Issues include the fuel pump (must be replaced with a Bosch), window regulator system, and engine faults like the mass airflow sensor and canister (disconnecting and reconnecting the MAF sensor is enough to turn off the warning light), warping of the...
Real driving pleasure: driving position, controls, mechanical feel, smooth and elastic engine (6-cylinder), engine sound, good acceleration, efficient soundproofing, balanced and playful handling, general comfort, good durability, beautiful interior and exterior material finish, accepts LPG conversion without issues. | Drawbacks: lacks a sixth gear, BMW dealerships are far too expensive (prefer an independent mechanic who often knows their stuff better), occasional noises over bumps, momentary fuel supply failure.
The clutch mechanism is problematic. Additionally, the engine management and airbag warning lights are illuminated.
Qualities: Driving comfort, reliability | Problems: Chassis torn at the rear axle, front suspension arm bushings worn at 60,000 km.
The car is nervous and reliable. However, maintenance is expensive. The clutch wore out prematurely! As did the shock absorbers! Etc...
This car has a comfortable ride with good acceleration when needed. However, it suffers from worn suspension bushings, an oil leak, and catalytic converter issues.
Very good performance and fuel economy, high-quality interior finishes, and comfortable ride. Limited trunk space and some engine reliability concerns. Engine failure at 220,000 km.
The 3 Series E46 is a very comfortable and enjoyable car to drive. However, the trunk is too small and its opening is not practical. It also suffers from a faulty ZKE unit and premature wear of the front axle.
The air conditioning system in this car has been problematic. Despite attempts to fix it, it continues to malfunction, impacting overall comfort, especially during warmer months. This is a significant drawback for daily use.
Problem: Alternator. Qualities: Finish / Reliability Engine Design Ergonomic mechanical rear-wheel drive Silent engine Battery in the trunk Easily accessible parts Soundproofing Reasonably reliable electronics Original sound even with HIFI pack Not too stiff despite 18-inch rims. Defects: Style starting to look old Lack of refinement and torque in 6-cylinder engines, especially before the 323i and without sport exhaust or tube. Many "merguez" on the market. The car has done its...
A very comfortable and economical car with advanced technology. The stereo automatically adjusts volume with speed, and it has semi-automatic wipers. However, the car ages poorly, showing fragility and creaking sounds. A significant issue is the turbo failure. The oil level warning light doesn't always activate for the turbo, leading to potential failure if pushed hard, as happened to me, resulting in engine damage.
A very good car overall, reliable and comfortable. It handles well, though fuel consumption is a bit high at 10l/100km. The sound of the gasoline six-cylinder is wonderful to listen to. It doesn't consume oil or water. Starts immediately despite 165,000 km and 20 years of age. Parts are generally very robust.
Comfortable, quiet, reliable, pleasant to drive, limited maintenance costs if you avoid the BMW dealership. Good capacity trunk. It never left me stranded, with good maintenance and a bit of DIY, it will take you anywhere in the world! Small defects include: window motor issues, slightly capricious heating, engine a bit weak at low revs. Non-existent infotainment, Bluetooth radio units will solve the problem. The valve cover gasket had to be changed every two years (40€ for the gasket, 1H of work, it's a common issue with the M52 engine), thermostat every two years (60€ and 2H of work), water pump at 150K km (80€, 3H).
Despite 15 years of loyal service, the interior is still like new. Beautiful sound, engine reliability, handling, comfort, driving pleasure, precise steering, excellent cruiser.
Qualities: Pretty, | Defects: Electronic problem | Problems: Electronics
The car has issues with the starter motor, particularly difficulty starting when cold, occurring irregularly. There are also problems with sensors, the vacuum pump, and the front arm mounting. On the positive side, the interior is quiet and well-maintained, with good motorway acceleration and handling.
Issue: Brake caliper. Handling is good (Michelin Primacy 3 tires). Plastic wear around the handbrake and other areas. Front wishbone bushings replaced at 100,000 km, ESP light came on then off, timing chain tensioner (noise on startup).
The engine is willing and quiet, but fuel consumption is high. It required changing front wishbone bushings (braking vibrations), rear brake hoses (rust), the tensioner and idler pulley for the belt, the alternator pulley, and an oil leak from the rocker cover gasket and vacuum pump. The infernal oil separator and its hoses also needed replacing. Electronic issues arose from a dead battery (car wouldn't start). The ventilation unit is broken, and the lighting (halogen) is poor.
Unrivaled BMW driving pleasure, the E46 is the most beautiful 3 Series and ages well. Very smooth gearbox, no diesel tractor noise. Economical and quiet, materials age well and the finish quality is above an E90 and E60. | Flaws: 143hp is a bit lacking, 30-40hp more is better, consumes a lot of oil, more than 1L/1000km, in my opinion the odometer has been tampered with, it shows 164,000km. It's the oil consumption of a rotary engine, without the pleasure of...
The BMW 3 Series E46 is a superb car, offering a great balance of performance, comfort, and style. It remains a highly desirable model for driving enthusiasts.
This 3 Series E46 is a very good car. It offers a great driving experience and solid reliability.
Engine oil consumption, idle actuator / fan / clutch / gearbox issues.
Qualities: comfort, reliability | Problems: crankcase ventilation filter, recurrent airbag warning light issue on E46
The car has several electrical issues, including a faulty oil filter housing, a bad mass airflow sensor, and an illuminated airbag light. These problems significantly impact the vehicle's performance and safety.
The 3 Series E46 is a great car with excellent handling and a smooth engine. However, the windshield is not resistant to cold, causing significant trouble in winter. Additionally, the headlights tend to accumulate a lot of moisture inside.
Reliable, economical, low maintenance. However, recurring issues include the airbag warning light, oil filter housing gasket leaks, triangle arm play, a poorly functioning lambda sensor, engine oil leaks, and the airbag warning light again.
Qualities: - Very quiet engine - Superb road holding - No mechanical problems | Defects: For me, the only defect is truly the fuel consumption | Problems: None
14-year-old car, no major issues, very reliable, excellent plastic quality. Even after years, plastics haven't degraded. Well-maintained inside and out, it truly doesn't show its age. Passenger airbag light, foggy headlights.
Qualities: - Easy to maintain - Decent fuel consumption for its weight - Timeless design - Endearing car | Defects: - Car is over 25 years old, so it has minor issues - 8-valve engine is a bit underpowered, though very pleasant to drive - Lacks a 6th gear | Problems: Many age-related issues (27 years old) but repairs are easily done: front power windows (thankfully, the rear ones on mine are manual), front wishbones (maintenance), actuator...
Less comfort, it's not a Citroën, yet I have a 2002 Citroën Saxo city car and regarding the seats, nothing to complain about. BMW, on the other hand, has nothing to complain about regarding the finish of this 3 Series 318i E46 from 2000. Very good engine, it's worth more than the heavier and slower-to-start 6-cylinder. Road holding, quality of materials, sound, no internal noise, doors close without issue. Normally, this German car at that time was billed between €28,000 and €30,000. Driving level at the top. Air flow meter, thermostat, airbag warning light at 100,000 km. Replacement of suspension wishbones, very mediocre braking, very mediocre comfort, seats after long distances. Air flow meter, thermostat, holes in acceleration, gearbox when cold, the first gear fails, gearbox not very precise, useless.
This BMW 3 Series E46 is very good. It offers great performance at high revs. However, keep an eye on the rear axle and be aware of potential issues with the airflow meter around 146,000 km.
Better than a Golf 5 1.9 TDI that stinks of poo. None (too beautiful, almost). None.
Exceptional chassis, smooth engine, excellent build quality, and quiet operation. The rear center seat is symbolic, and fuel consumption in the city is excessive.
Qualities: comfort, engine smoothness, build quality, fuel consumption | Problems: engine warning light on ??
The car is pleasant to drive with a nice sound. However, there are electronic issues, specifically with the lambda sensor and injectors. The electronic lambda sensor is a recurring problem.
Comfortable, with a successful design that isn't flashy. Enjoyable to drive despite the 105hp. It can handle the highway without issue. The engine is very accessible for maintenance.
Driving quality. Feeling of security. Smooth gearbox despite its age, precise steering. Comfortable. Reliable overall. A bit thirsty for fuel. Occasional metallic noise when stopped. Lacks torque. Exhaust sensor at 295,000 km.
The car suffered from several issues, including a leaking coolant flange behind the cylinder head, an oil breather air leak, and an oil leak at the oil filter housing. Additionally, there were problems with the links, rear shock absorber mounts, lambda sensors, and the rocker cover gasket. Despite these issues, the car offered good comfort, soundproofing, and equipment.
Excellent comfort, quality finishes, and a timeless design. However, it can lack power, and common issues include the expansion tank, leaking radiator, unstable idle, and air mass meter. This is my third BMW with this engine, and the expansion tank has failed on all three.
Driving a BMW is a pleasure, the dashboard is simple, very stable, pleasant on the highway, nice push from 3000-3500 RPM. Downsides include fuel consumption, it's quite large and annoying in the city, and issues with the windows. Battery and window problems reported.
Issue: Power window motor, but it's not a big deal.
Qualities: rear-wheel drive, insurance/maintenance costs, comfort, high-RPM power | Defects: low-RPM lag, rear space | Issues: none in 45,000km
Qualities: Very good driving comfort. Good soundproofing. Powerful engine for a 7hp that feels like a 10hp from French brands. Many accessories: reversing alarm, automatic wipers, electric windows and mirrors. It's a small sporty car, the cheapest model to buy and maintain. | Flaws: A bit heavy, doesn't handle bad weather conditions well (rain, snow, ice), price of parts and repairs too high. | Problems:
Hidden defect. Oil leak, 2 radiators changed and still the same leak in the same place. Rear left axle torn off (a recognized BMW problem). Some electrical issues.
Qualities: Rear-wheel drive, engine, steering, gearbox, chassis, braking, comfort, soundproofing, finish (plastic and assembly), driving position ergonomics, fuel consumption on roads and highways. Flaws: City fuel consumption, transmission tunnel (rear seats), tight boot. Seats lack lumbar support. Problems: Left and right power window motors tired, oil leak from rocker cover gasket.
Reliable, enduring engine that handles high revs flawlessly. Fuel consumption is anemic in eco-driving. Reasonable insurance/maintenance. Timeless design, excellent driving position. Controls are well-placed: steering wheel, gear lever, pedals, mirrors. The chassis is devilishly effective. Rear-wheel drive combined with this chassis is a joy in curves, turns, and hairpins. However, some assembly and material finishing issues: carpets tear, exterior door trims peel, steering wheel leather tears, mediocre connectors. Clutch, flex plate, front/rear suspension, various minor engine sensors have no impact on driving and don't cause breakdowns or engine stops, thankfully. The gearbox is robust but ages...
Alternative comparisons will appear here soon.
Add your email-verified report to help other BMW 3 Series E46 owners.