Problem: Clutch
Qualities: Comfort, equipment, modularity. Flaws: Body roll, wind noise. Problems: Clutch.
Model and generation reliability insights from verified owners. Variants are selected when adding reviews.
Owners rate reliability 3.2/5 across 20 owner reviews.
Most reported issues:
These ratings and mentions are owner evidence, not a prediction of failure probability.
Mentioned in 5 of 20 owner reviews.
The car is very comfortable with a large boot and good acceleration from the 130 hp engine. However, there are significant vibrations and noise in the steering. The glove box design with side…
Read the owner review
Mentioned in 4 of 20 owner reviews.
Problem with the right front steering that jerks during low-speed maneuvers. Very unpleasant with strong jolts in the steering wheel. Citroën has been evading since the beginning, even though the…
Read the owner review
Mentioned in 4 of 20 owner reviews.
The car's electronic systems are problematic, leading to unpredictable behavior and malfunctions.
Read the owner review
Mentioned in 3 of 20 owner reviews.
Nervous, agile. Steering too sensitive: constant concentration needed at the wheel. Clutch overheats when starting on a hill (with automatic assist): persistent smell outside and even inside the…
Read the owner review
Mentioned in 3 of 20 owner reviews.
Good engine before the belt issue. Engine fault, get vehicle repaired. Citroen replaced the engine... covering 80% of the operation. AC fan noise issue. Another 1.2 PureTech from March 2017 lost its…
Read the owner review
One review can mention several issues. Categories reflect owner tagging; excerpts describe individual experiences and may not discuss the tagged issue.
Methodology: only approved, email-validated reviews available in the active language for this generation are included. These are self-selected owner experiences, not a representative survey.
20 of 20 owner reviews identify an engine. Fewer than five reviews is marked as limited data, an editorial threshold. Ratings describe these owners' experiences, not an engine ranking.
| Engine | Owner reliability rating | Reviews | Most reported issues |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.2 PureTech (131 Hp) (HN05) | 3.0/5 | 7 | No categories reported; not evidence of fault-free ownership. |
| 1.2 PureTech (131 Hp) Automatic (HN05) | 3.3/5 | 13 | No categories reported; not evidence of fault-free ownership. |
Qualities: Comfort, equipment, modularity. Flaws: Body roll, wind noise. Problems: Clutch.
The car's electronic systems are problematic, leading to unpredictable behavior and malfunctions.
I just drove from Clermont Ferrand to Cholet on the highway with the cruise control set to 130 km/h, and I'm a bit surprised by the fuel consumption. 7.8 liters per 100 km. What do you think? I find it to be... too much compared to the vehicle's stated figures.
Spacious, modular, reasonable fuel consumption on long journeys, elevated driving position. However, fuel consumption is high on short trips, and there's abnormal tire wear on 4-season Hankook tires, less than 10,000 km.
Comfortable and well-equipped, it's a pleasure to drive. Not very noisy, its fuel consumption is reasonable at 6.2 L. Relatively spacious for its class.
Good engine before the belt issue. Engine fault, get vehicle repaired. Citroen replaced the engine... covering 80% of the operation. AC fan noise issue. Another 1.2 PureTech from March 2017 lost its engine... 3-year lifespan!! Following a belt issue that apparently disintegrated.
Problem with the right front steering that jerks during low-speed maneuvers. Very unpleasant with strong jolts in the steering wheel. Citroën has been evading since the beginning, even though the vehicle was under warranty, claiming it's a manufacturing defect and there's nothing to be done or contested. Which is, to say the least, absolutely scandalous! Vehicle brand to avoid.
Comfortable, pleasant to drive, quite a large trunk. I love its height, its handling, you feel safe. Reliability is a concern. At 50,000 km, the car requested a garage visit for a timing belt change, fully covered. It pulls to the right in corners. I hope it won't have any more timing belt issues...
Nervous, agile. Steering too sensitive: constant concentration needed at the wheel. Clutch overheats when starting on a hill (with automatic assist): persistent smell outside and even inside the cabin. Clutch overheats.
No positives. Big disappointment with this brand choice. Very noisy on ring roads and highways. Very stiff suspension, every little bump makes the whole car move. Noisy ventilation. Headlight illumination is very poor. Wish it had LED as standard. Disappointed with this vehicle choice. Very stiff and noisy suspension.
The car is very comfortable with a large boot and good acceleration from the 130 hp engine. However, there are significant vibrations and noise in the steering. The glove box design with side openings is impractical, often causing objects to block closure. The GPS is positioned too low, which can be dangerous. There's a lack of storage space. A recall occurred a year later for steering vibrations, but the issue remains unresolved.
Driving this car is a real pleasure, far from being a sluggish vehicle as some reviewers suggest. The suspensions aren't as soft as they seem, and overtaking is a breeze with a 0-100 km/h time of 9.3 seconds. On the highway at 130 km/h, consumption is 6.5 L/100km, but much higher in the city. The lane departure warning is annoying outside of highways, and the airbag light occasionally illuminates.
Comfort, look, braking, power of the 1.2L 130hp. Significant body roll, pitching sensation, interior plastic quality. Very high fuel consumption (130hp petrol), even more so as the real consumption doesn't match the manufacturer's figures. The onboard computer shows about 10% less fuel consumption. Intentional deception or not, Citroën needs to explain.
The air conditioning system has a problem. This is a significant issue, especially during warmer weather, impacting overall comfort inside the cabin. The rest of the vehicle's features are generally well-received, but this specific malfunction is a major drawback.
The car has a pleasant look, a nice engine with sufficient power and torque for its type. Driving pleasure and comfort are good, as is the trunk volume. There are many customization options. However, there's a lack of storage compartments (floor hatches, under-seat drawers, glasses holder). The glove box isn't very practical. The fuel tank volume is too small. Too many options are still offered for the Shine trim level (family pack, park assist, grip control, hands-free opening, etc.). There was an issue with the fuel tank overflowing when filling, but this was resolved by replacing the tank.
The car has good comfort, quietness, driving pleasure, and assembly quality. However, its range is limited, there's no passenger armrest, the gearbox can be jerky in city driving, there's a lack of practical storage, and it's less practical than my old Xsara Picasso. Customer service communication is poor. Many functions are unnecessary, and the Citroën app has bugs. The air conditioning leaked in the first year.
Engine is dynamic (but sometimes the front axle falters). Overall comfort (despite some body roll). Spacious interior. Nice look. Quality of plastics and assembly has improved. Fuel consumption (at a steady 130 km/h on the highway, consumption is higher than my Audi A5 252 hp...). Reliability of the onboard computer is lacking (consumption, range...). My Citroen updates are problematic. Standard tires are lamentable (2 punctures in a few months - compared to 1 in 35 years previously). Difficult to find a replacement tire. 3 weeks wait the first time, and the second time had to change both tires on the axle (Bridgestone Turanza not found in France according to the Citroen garage!!!). Mediocre quality tires and inability for Citroen to find a replacement tire. Electronics (navigation system update issues).
Good comfort in the city and on the road (except for the lumbar support on the front seats). Very pleasant driving experience in the city and on the road. Poor lumbar support on the front seats: we had to buy memory foam cushions. A new 8-speed automatic gearbox would be welcome as it's more pleasant and consumes less. No problems to date, but the car is new. Given the reviews published by owners (thank you!), I will have the timing belt examined very regularly.
A steering issue has been noted. Otherwise, the car offers good accessibility, driving position, acceleration, and overtaking safety. Visibility to the sides and rear is excellent, as are the parking sensors and reverse camera. The interior finish is high quality, the trunk is adaptable, and fuel consumption is reasonable (5.6 to 5.8 liters/100km at 110 km/h on the highway with cruise control). Steering precision is also a plus. The main drawbacks are a lack of a central storage compartment with the driver's armrest, sensitivity to strong crosswinds, and a limited fuel tank capacity for long journeys (700 to 750 km range). No other issues were observed.
Everything is fine for now: very large, easily modular trunk, eye-level screen very practical and pleasant for driving, problem-free and fatigue-free driving on long journeys. Good road holding. Rather spacious and very modular interior. Vehicle less than 18 months old so "clean".
Alternative comparisons will appear here soon.
Add your email-verified report to help other Citroën C5 Aircross I owners.