Problem: Gearbox
Excellent car, good sound insulation and handling, reasonable power and fuel consumption, 7-speed gearbox is perfect.
Model and generation reliability insights from verified owners. Variants are selected when adding reviews.
Owners rate reliability 3.5/5 across 93 owner reviews.
Most reported issues:
These ratings and mentions are owner evidence, not a prediction of failure probability.
Mentioned in 23 of 93 owner reviews.
Beyond 130,000 km, prepare your wallet. A succession of problems past this mileage. Over €3,000 in repairs in the same year...
Read the owner review
Mentioned in 22 of 93 owner reviews.
Defects: Front suspension failed (faulty). GPS impossible to navigate, breakdown. Problems: Suspension, navigation, handling?
Read the owner review
Mentioned in 21 of 93 owner reviews.
Excellent car, good sound insulation and handling, reasonable power and fuel consumption, 7-speed gearbox is perfect.
Read the owner review
Mentioned in 11 of 93 owner reviews.
Issues: Injection relay, auto gearbox reprogramming, main engine, xenon headlights.
Read the owner review
Mentioned in 11 of 93 owner reviews.
The power steering system has developed issues. Specifically, certain parts are of poor quality, and the power steering pump is completely broken.
Read the owner review
One review can mention several issues. Categories reflect owner tagging; excerpts describe individual experiences and may not discuss the tagged issue.
Methodology: only approved, email-validated reviews available in the active language for this generation are included. These are self-selected owner experiences, not a representative survey.
93 of 93 owner reviews identify an engine. Fewer than five reviews is marked as limited data, an editorial threshold. Ratings describe these owners' experiences, not an engine ranking.
| Engine | Owner reliability rating | Reviews | Most reported issues |
|---|---|---|---|
| C 200 CDI (136 Hp) (OM 646.811) | 3.4/5 | 53 | No categories reported; not evidence of fault-free ownership. |
| C 220 CDI (170 Hp) (OM 646.811) | 3.7/5 | 40 | No categories reported; not evidence of fault-free ownership. |
Excellent car, good sound insulation and handling, reasonable power and fuel consumption, 7-speed gearbox is perfect.
Reliable. Interior finish: center console trim is peeling off.
Beyond 130,000 km, prepare your wallet. A succession of problems past this mileage. Over €3,000 in repairs in the same year...
Comfortable ride, great engine performance, and spacious interior. However, the rear-wheel drive, and especially the electrical and electronic issues, are a major drawback. At 130,000 km, we experienced electrical and electronic problems, along with a water pump failure.
Smooth engine, pleasant 7-speed automatic gearbox. A bit noisy. First problem at only 4000 km, isn't that a bit early? Significant coolant leak (1.5 liters added). I will see the dealership tomorrow.
Experiencing issues with the dual-mass flywheel. It's causing noticeable vibrations and a rougher driving experience, especially at lower RPMs. This is a known problem with some models and can lead to costly repairs if not addressed.
Issues: Injection relay, auto gearbox reprogramming, main engine, xenon headlights.
Defects: Front suspension failed (faulty). GPS impossible to navigate, breakdown. Problems: Suspension, navigation, handling?
A very good car that offers a great balance of safety, comfort, and handling. The only minor issue encountered was an IT problem.
The C-Class T-Model S204 is a very good car. Rear space is a bit tight, and the mirrors squeak.
Qualities: Very reliable. Defects: noisy engine during acceleration. Problems: none.
Delighted despite its age. However, tires wear quickly (18). Headlight adjustment is electric and broken. Sunroof is also broken.
Stiff suspension with 225/45/17 tires. Water pump failed at 90,000 km and is currently at the Mercedes garage.
The power steering system has developed issues. Specifically, certain parts are of poor quality, and the power steering pump is completely broken.
Excellent comfort, high-quality finish, and attractive design. The only minor drawbacks are fuel consumption and occasional minor electronic glitches, such as squeaking mirrors.
The car's suspension is surprisingly quiet and contributes to a very pleasing aesthetic line. Fuel consumption is also excellent.
On good roads, the comfort is excellent. However, inside, the entire electrical system operates keylessly. This is dangerous in case of accidental operation, and the battery will be quickly drained.
The car has a power steering issue, specifically a "cremallere de direction" problem. This affects its handling on snow. The interior quality is good and the road handling is decent otherwise.
Comfortable, well-built interior, quiet ride, and good driving position. Steering radius is impressive. While performance is adequate, the weight slightly impacts high-speed agility. Gear changes from D to R can be very slow.
Nice car, but that's all. Very bad and misleading advertising with 170 control points for a used car. My Mercedes has so many problems it's unbelievable. It's an abuse of trust deserving of a lawsuit. Too many issues to list.
General reliability, competent after-sales service, no major breakdowns. However, road noise, body resonance in wagon versions, and tricky handling in the rain are notable downsides. Additionally, there's an irregular idle and the automatic gearbox is sluggish when downshifting.
Qualities: very good on the road, comfortable, pleasant. Defects: fuel consumption, caution needed in winter... Problems: water pump and electronic issue unresolved to date (engine fault light comes on occasionally). The garage has not yet found the problem. Fortunately, car bought from Nearly New Car Belgium with a 3-year warranty extension.
The car is quite comfortable but heavy. Injectors needed replacement at 80,000 km, and the ELO (likely referring to Exhaust Gas Recirculation valve or similar) at 110,000 km. It hesitates slightly between 1500 and 2000 RPM during acceleration.
The car is very pleasant to drive, with a perfect automatic gearbox. There are no issues.
This C-Class T-Model S204 is a very good car. No significant issues were encountered during its use. However, at 88,000 km, an internal hernia was found in the boost hose.
Issues: Interior fan and climate control module replaced.
Qualities: acceleration, 7-speed automatic gearbox | Flaws: a bit noisy, ridiculous storage space | Problems: repetitive coolant loss
The car's gearbox has issues. Despite good handling, acoustic comfort, elegant design, and excellent finish, it suffers from a noisy engine, squeaky mirrors in the rain, and a high price with options. Rear space is limited for taller passengers, and its used purchase price is higher than competitors. However, it boasts good power-to-consumption ratio, safety, torque, smooth automatic transmission, precise steering (AMG pack), brand prestige, and rarity compared to the 3 Series and A4.
Reliable engine, only issue: fuel temperature sensor. Two doors (front right and rear left) no longer open/close by remote. Both headlight units burnt out due to parking light bulb overheating. Rear headlight units: connectors burnt out due to overheating of too small ground connection and too thin ground wire. Radio/phone selector axis broken (plastic, too weak). Seems to be a very frequent problem.
Excellent road manners and sufficient power. Smooth and torquey engine. Occasionally lively. Road noise, dull interior, and not enough storage. Water pump and injectors were replaced under a free Mercedes recall at 100,000 km, which reduced fuel consumption by 0.7 L/100 km.
The car is comfortable, surprisingly quiet on the highway at 130 km/h, and has good fuel economy. However, the engine noise at idle is unbearable, and the suspension is a bit firm on country roads. Despite these issues, I have 102,000 km and it's regularly serviced at Mercedes. No other problems!
Mechanical excellence (I've been using Mercedes for almost 40 years). However, the bodywork is too fragile. A crack in the rear crossmember was discovered when it was on the verge of breaking (the crossmember supports the entire rear axle, which risked falling onto the road with a bump).
Mechanical reliability issues. The orange engine light came on before Service A, there's a hesitation during acceleration, and a suspicious noise on startup. To be continued, as it's going in for service soon.
Excellent value for money. Consumes little, comfortable and prestigious. However, it lacks power and USB connectivity.
Overall comfort, turning radius, beautiful car, doesn't depreciate quickly. However, rear axle noises (shocks?) that Mercedes couldn't find, which is frustrating. Intercooler appears to be leaking according to Mercedes, but it still drives well. Electronic issues include the rear stop light staying on after locking, and once the radiator fan ran at full speed while the AC/heater stopped working, with no buttons responding.
Qualities: styling, road holding, build quality, soundproofing | Faults: fuel consumption, comfort (firm) | Problems: accessory pulley changed at 50,000 km (cold noise), 1st gear sometimes jumps out (manual gearbox. Poorly engaged ???
After 200,000 km, many expensive electronic failures. Defective sensor causing limp mode. Exorbitant repair costs at Mercedes dealer. Not reliable given the car's price. Deficient electronics, interior. Radio.
This car is a good cruiser and very maneuverable. However, the plastic quality is poor, with paint flaking off buttons. The accessory belt tensioner and belt also pose a problem.
The central console's plastic feels cheap, but the brakes have exceptional durability and the engine doesn't consume a drop of oil. However, seat adjustments are incomplete, and the front lights are weak. Additionally, one rear light circuit board failed at 120,000 km.
This car offers a comfortable and pleasant driving experience with a high-quality finish. However, storage space is limited, and rear-seat comfort could be improved. There have been reports of injector seal and flywheel issues.
The 7G automatic transmission is smooth and offers effective acceleration for easy overtaking. The car is very agile, even in the city. The engine is a bit noisy, and the ride is firm on poor road surfaces. It was expensive to buy with options (€53,000), but a discount of €5,500 brought it down to €47,500. No significant issues so far, perhaps a slight squeak in the left electric mirror.
The car's bodywork and comfort are good. However, the automatic gearbox response is slow, fuel consumption is too high, and there are electronic issues with the control unit, engine mounts, and gearbox.
Silence, comfort, and driving pleasure. Reasonable consumption (6.0l/100km over 20,000km). Lacks storage, small and not high enough boot.
The car has good flexibility, acceleration, and fuel economy. However, it lacks storage space and has poor rear visibility. The accessory belt had to be replaced at 155,000 km.
Style, comfort, material quality, fuel economy, perfect for everyday use. I drove it daily for 4 years, covered over 150,000 km, a very reliable and robust vehicle, I highly recommend it. Soundproofing could be improved to my taste. Otherwise, overall it's an excellent vehicle, I highly recommend it. Water pump and accessory belt pulleys, a common issue on this model. Suspension link (classic wear).
Black screen after 4.5 years of use, but CD, radio, etc. are in good working order. What explains this?
Once seated inside, a sense of well-being from the visual to the serenity and feeling of security. Luxurious ambiance without ostentation. The automatic gearbox is a pure marvel. A car you want to take everywhere, you never get tired of it. In short, a Mercedes with 'soul' that you love like a serious fiancée who never disappoints and is most beautiful when you're in love. Also note the pleasant adaptive lighting.
The engine itself is good, and the BA5 transmission is reliable. However, there are issues with the water pump and the oil filter housing.
Strengths: Comfort, fuel efficiency, reliability, maintenance. The optional 'car cinema' offers rare sound and visual quality for its age. The engine is well-suited to the vehicle's use and size. The presence of simple, practical everyday accessories and automatisms, which Mercedes doesn't highlight. Weaknesses: Because one must be found: the first gear of the manual gearbox is too short. It's not a family car despite good habitability where four adults will easily find...
Qualities: Looks, perceived quality, willing engine even with the 5-speed automatic transmission. | Defects: After-sales service offers little support for its many issues, despite 100% Mercedes maintenance... | Problems: Pulls to the right, stiff rear suspension, significant oil leak in the crankcase, coolant consumption even after water pump replacement, constant DRL failures (there are 4!), rear lights flickering due to undersized ground wire, and for the past week, ESP/ABS control unit.
Excellent on the road, fuel consumption of 6l or less (80% highway) with smooth driving (without dragging!). At 360,000 km, I've only just replaced discs and pads for the second time! Michelin tires last about 60,000 km. Smooth, anticipatory driving and respecting warm-up times allow for real savings on fuel, brakes, tires, and shock absorbers (never changed), ball joints (never changed). Oil changes every 25,000 km without...
Reliability (400,000 km on the same clutch) reasonable consumption (approx. 6-6.5l) smooth driving, 80% road driving. I've replaced brake pads and discs for the second time at over 350,000 km, still on the original shocks, ball joints, etc. Technical inspection practically clear. Resale value is excellent, especially for a car of this age. Acceleration quality: after a recent mass airflow sensor change, I'm getting back its youthful performance!! Tire consumption Michelin 60,000 km approx. no oil top-up between oil changes (every 15,000 km).
Comfortable but road noise (tires?). Sticky steering: follows road imperfections too closely. 4-cylinder a bit rough at low revs. Result: if you let go of the steering wheel, a second later you're in the right lane. After 3 modifications by the dealership (Valence Etoile du Rhone), same problem and with vibrations appearing in the front axle!!! I sold the vehicle...
The 5-speed automatic transmission is very smooth and adequate with this very, very pleasant 170hp engine. However, the shock absorbers are harsh. The Mercedes-Benz SAV at Garage Jousselin 45 in ORLEANS is awful! Recurring defects found and listed here and there all happen to me, and this Mercedes Jousselin 45 in ORLEANS lacks the honesty to admit responsibility (electronic ignition switch with random operation, insufficient section of the ground wire for the 2 rear lights with risk of burning the harness, etc.). The electronic ignition switch is broken and the support is cracked! The ESP/ABS unit is also defective and needs replacement 57 km after my B1 service, likely due to the brake fluid replacement: 1800€ covered only at 50% + 500€ for the service!
Driving comfort is pleasant. However, the car consistently pulls to the right despite garage intervention. There's a knocking sound from the shock absorbers on rough roads. The upholstery sags quickly, even with infrequent rear passengers (which is disappointing for a car of this class). At 100,000 km, the right taillight circuit board failed due to an undersized ground wire. Mercedes offers a kit with thicker cables to connect with a workaround, but doesn't acknowledge the hidden defect. I repaired it myself. At 150,000 km, the GPS media jog dial became inoperable when rotating; it's not yet repaired as it's still usable, but estimated Mercedes repair cost is €200 for the part plus €200 for labor. I will repair it myself for €70. The front left door lock actuator failed at 156,000 km, with an estimated Mercedes repair cost of €500. I will repair it myself using a €2.50 part from the original Chinese supplier with the same reference.
Super road holding! Plenty of space, well-soundproofed, general quality of the car, it's a Mercedes, heavy doors, you can feel the quality, exceptional engine for a 4-cylinder diesel, good gearbox, good braking too, interior quite nice, everything is well thought out, refrigerated glove box for example, plenty of sockets everywhere in the trunk too. Command system complex but you get used to it quickly. In short, for now it's very largely positive. I was hesitating between this and a Passat, well I'm not...
The primary issue with this car lies in its suspension. While it offers a premium sedan experience, the ride comfort is significantly compromised on rough roads. Hitting manhole covers and potholes results in a jarring experience, especially at speeds below 80 km/h due to its firm tuning. Additionally, there have been reported problems with the airflow meter.
The 170 hp suit it wonderfully. I even think it's the right ratio, even if 20 or 30 hp more would be top. The accelerations are frank and "masterful" for this type of vehicle with this weight/power/volume/footprint ratio. The automatic transmission, even if it doesn't react as quickly as DSG (VAG), is still remarkable in use, although it tends to be slow and sometimes rev very high, especially when cold (probably due to viscosity). The design has really rejuvenated MERCEDES' image and even gives it a connotation of "sportiness". It quickly becomes a flat wagon. The headliner fabric is too soft and fragile. After owning 3 AUDIs (the last one being an A6 quattro 2.5L Tdi), I just got a Mercedes. I will therefore give you my general feeling: General comfort is less good than AUDI. Road noise... Around 25,000 km: repeated loss of coolant, but everything was covered under warranty (the first time = water pump... the second time = leak at the diesel heater).
I had already posted a review at 400,000 km (June 2022) with a score of 19/20. I bought it in July 2013 with 124,000 km (Avantgarde model, June 2009), already betting on its reputation for robustness. Today I confirm this opinion with an additional 120,000 km with no major issues since. It's an excellent long-distance car. Its mileage testifies to exceptional reliability (same gearbox, same shock absorbers). It's true that I always respect the warm-up time for the engine.
Reliable and economical engine, low fuel consumption. Great driving comfort, very pleasant. Engine power is slightly insufficient, despite good torque feel (thanks to RWD). Engine 200 is adapted for relaxed, economical use. DPF pressure sensor clogging, water pump.
Driving experience is good for an entry-level model. It's well-equipped, with a very attractive design. It's beautiful with the Mercedes logo on the grille. It has a five-door coupe look, resembling a sports car.
Qualities: Fuel consumption, design | Defects: Slightly firm ride | Problems: Water pumps, shock absorbers, and steering tie rod
Engine reliability issues! Problems with the water pump, front suspension (knocking noises), and injectors (cold start difficulties).
A very good, reliable car with no issues. Regular maintenance at Mercedes. Very good road handling, used mainly on mountain roads and highways.
The car is reliable, very comfortable, and the gearbox is smooth. It's also pleasant on the highway. However, there aren't many interior storage options.
Excellent highway cruiser, economical with normal, code-respecting driving, pleasant front cabin. Rear is more restricted, though it can be managed with proper distribution. Blind spot visibility isn't great.
Good road holding, pleasant for long distances. Lacks a bit of punch and night lighting is a bit limited. The intensity of the rear lighting on the left side is weaker.
The car is comfortable and spacious. However, it lacks a bit of power due to its heavy weight. It also has too many optional extras, like anti-theft bolts (150 euros at Mercedes, etc.), which should be standard on this type of model. No issues besides wear and tear parts like brake pads, shock absorbers, and routine maintenance (oil change).
Issue: Water pump failed + Alternator failed at 124,000 km.
Avantgarde model, at least. Top driving position. 125,000 km without issues in 5 years. Maintenance outside the dealership was very cheap, e.g., Norauto. Suspension easily bottoms out. Tank too small, but still 800 km range. Sporty driving without brutality. Water pump.
A very good car. Quiet driving, good handling, fuel-efficient, and comfortable. The only downside is the lack of rear seat space. No real problems encountered.
Problem: Injectors at 130,000 km = €2,000, NOT covered by Mercedes. According to the network, this is normal at this mileage??? Heavy driver, including 2 Peugeot 405 diesels over 280,000 km, where everything was original (battery, and… INJECTORS!!!). I informed Customer Service that there was no point in sending me ads anymore: like Capri, MERCEDES it's over. | Problems: Injectors, water pump, coolant leak not resolved by the network!!!
Car used almost exclusively on the highway, original clutch. Comfort, Reliability, Fuel Consumption. Power for a 200 CDI but acceptable for normal use. Torque in the mountains lacks punch, especially when loaded. ELV EZS known defect. Rear subframe rusted and eventually broke. Apart from the two problems mentioned above, nothing to report despite the mileage.
Fault: Clutch. Qualities: comfortable | Defects: unreliable, small trunk | Problems: injectors changed at 65,000 km, engine mounts, flywheel and clutch at 69,000 km (worn by defective flywheel), water pump 69,000 km, multifunction dial HS. Vehicle under a Star warranty, injectors, flywheel, dial, and water pump covered. Still in dispute for the rest. 850? in costs on a vehicle owned for 6 months. Now the driver's electric window is acting up... Mercedes for
This car suffers from recurring injection system problems, including injector issues, leaks, and glow plug failure. The turbocharger has also broken down. While it offers good highway fuel economy and comfortable interior, the fragile engine is a major concern.
Good car, AMG trim. However, maintenance is expensive. Experienced a power steering anti-theft lock failure at 134,000 km for 900 euros in March 2015. The driver's seat's faux leather is not of good quality and was already replaced under warranty before 2 years.
Comfortable and pleasant to drive. However, with Mercedes, there's always a breakdown before 40,000 km: turbo, injector diesel leak, fuel pump, power steering. The diesel leak is recurrent with Mercedes. I've owned four new C-Class cars. At 10,000 km, a diesel leak (sensor) sprayed onto the rear wheels, causing the vehicle to skid. Mercedes' response: the vehicle is compliant with its series.
The car is cramped. Keyless entry failed at 50,000 km. Rain sensor malfunctioned at 120,000 km. Water pump and hydraulic unit needed replacement at 177,000 km.
The seats and ride comfort are good. However, there are issues with the water pump (coolant leak), a faulty DPF sensor, a fuel filter housing leak (coolant leak), a broken right rear light assembly, a damaged dashboard/GPS dial, and paint clear coat chips.
The car holds the road exceptionally well, but I've encountered several issues. The accessory belts needed replacing at 70,000 km. The clear coat on the roof has delaminated, and the paint itself is quite fragile. The camshaft sensor also failed.
Overall good design, living up to the brand's reputation. However, comfort is lacking, especially in the front seats. The front shock absorbers failed at 68,000 km.
Excellent silence, smooth ride, good handling, and more than honorable performance. Electric mirrors creak. Car is delicate on snow, but this is known for MBs and not just them. One dipped beam bulb failed. Dealership proactively recalled to change the oil pump ('noisy bearings').
The automatic transmission and the interior volume are pleasant. However, road holding on wet surfaces is a concern. The driver's seat's synthetic leather is cracking, and there are suspicious noises when reversing (perhaps suspension related?). The car is going in for its A service at Mercedes soon.
The car boasts an appealing design and excellent build quality, providing a smooth ride on the highway. However, there are some minor drawbacks concerning equipment, such as the lack of electrically folding mirrors and a rain sensor. Additionally, some parts have required warranty repairs, including the front shock absorber, noisy wheel bearings, and tailgate struts.
Interior and exterior finish of very good quality, ergonomics, general comfort. However, issues with steering and price. Water pump replaced under warranty, radiator fan motor problem (runs constantly) plus electronic controls out of warranty, costing approximately €1000.00 including installation.
The car is incredibly durable. However, the seats lack cushioning, and there have been significant issues with the steering lock at 240,000 km and the injectors at 120,000 km.
The car has issues with premature wear of front brake discs and pads, as well as the leatherette interior trim on the steering wheel and seats. There's been a significant oil leak for over 18 months, unresolved despite multiple mechanics and official MB service. A persistent clunking sound from the rear left wheel on paved roads remains unfixable. The right rear light assembly was replaced twice due to burnt wires, the interior mirror bulb squeaks, and numerous other smaller issues have led to costly repairs and expensive routine maintenance.
Accessible mechanics for DIY enthusiasts. Steering column issues, but the locking motor can be preemptively replaced for around 30 euros on eBay! Rear light connectors known to burn out. Injector seals: do them preventatively before caramelization occurs! With a warm engine, change all 4 seals in 2 hours, even if you've never done it before (just need a torque wrench and new bolts).
Comfort, fuel consumption 5.5l loaded this summer on highway roads, quiet car except during acceleration as with many models. 7-speed automatic gearbox very pleasant, except for the sequential mode, which isn't great compared to my old V60. Electric tailgate, trunk/cabin partition net. Road holding, directional xenon lights, original audio very good for me. Road holding on wet surfaces, be careful not to get caught. Sequential mode on the automatic gearbox. The previous owner had an injector and water pump changed at 100,000 km. For me, nothing so far.
This car has been a constant source of problems. It's unreliable, with issues ranging from unexplained noises requiring shock absorber replacement, to dashboard warnings due to a disconnected passenger seat sensor. The water pump was replaced, there was a small oil leak, and the multifunction screen needed changing. The gas trap oil motor failed, leading to engine racing or deceleration on the highway. We also had defective connecting rods, and the front/rear radar LEDs went haywire while driving. The horn malfunctioned, and the accelerator pedal had to be replaced due to squeaking.
The car generally offers a smooth ride, good fuel economy, and a quiet cabin except during acceleration. It handles well, has excellent peripheral visibility, and generous front seating. Highway comfort is a strong point, and the air conditioning is very effective. However, the steering can feel sticky in city driving, and the car's weight is noticeable. Rear space and trunk capacity are just adequate, and comfort suffers on rough roads. Specific issues encountered were a faulty water pump, front shock absorbers, and the car radio, all of which were covered under warranty.
The car has a firm suspension, but you get used to it. The run-flat tires wear unevenly, with a slight noise when engaging the clutch when hot. Is it the clutch?
Front seats are uncomfortable (hard padding), suspension is bumpy on bad roads. Fragile air vents (front & rear). Finish is rather ordinary for a German car (but it's the basic 'classic' model) and certainly no better than Peugeot or Citroen cars in the same category. Tire pressure warning system is unreliable. Electric window operation has issues at high speeds. Gearbox handling...
Alternative comparisons will appear here soon.
Add your email-verified report to help other Mercedes-Benz C-class T-modell S204 owners.